LMTD correction in multi–shell-pass exchangers In a shell-and-tube heat exchanger, how does the LMTD correction factor FT change when the number of shell passes is increased (for the same terminal temperatures and number of tube passes)?

Chemical Engineering Process Equipment and Plant Design Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    increases
  • B
    decreases
  • C
    remains same
  • D
    remains same, only if the number of tube passes does not change.

Answer

Correct Answer: increases

Explanation

Introduction / Context:The log-mean temperature difference (LMTD) method is widely used to size heat exchangers. For non-ideal flow arrangements (not purely counter-current), a correction factor FT is applied to the LMTD of an equivalent counter-current exchanger. Understanding how FT varies with flow arrangement—especially the number of shell passes—is vital for practical design and debottlenecking.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Same inlet and outlet temperatures of hot and cold streams (same terminal temperature differences).
  • Tube pass configuration is held fixed while increasing the number of shell passes.
  • No phase change; sensible heat exchange context.

Concept / Approach:FT quantifies departure from ideal counter-current behavior. Increasing shell passes tends to distribute temperature driving force more effectively along the exchanger, making the arrangement closer to counter-current. As a result, FT moves upward toward 1.0. Designers often prefer 1–2 or 2–4 arrangements precisely because they achieve higher FT than a single-pass 1–1 cross-flow–like pattern.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Hold terminal temperatures constant so LMTD for a true counter-current reference is fixed.Increase shell passes: flow pattern approaches counter-current segments.As approach to counter-current improves, the required correction decreases.Therefore FT increases (moves closer to 1).

Verification / Alternative check:TEMA charts of FT versus temperature effectiveness and heat capacity rate ratio show higher FT values for multi–shell-pass arrangements at the same operating points.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Decreases/remains same: Contradicts FT charts and the counter-current approximation.
  • “Remains same, only if tube passes do not change”: Even at fixed tube passes, FT rises with more shell passes.

Common Pitfalls:Confusing FT with overall U or with LMTD itself; FT is a dimensionless multiplier tied to flow arrangement and terminal temperatures.

Final Answer:increases

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion