Voltmeter loading — under what condition can the loading effect of a voltmeter be neglected when measuring the voltage across some resistance in a circuit?
-
AThe measured voltage is very high
-
BThe measured voltage is very low
-
CThe meter resistance is at least 10 times greater than the resistance being measured across
-
DThe meter resistance is at least 10 times less than the resistance being measured across
Answer
Correct Answer: The meter resistance is at least 10 times greater than the resistance being measured across
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Real voltmeters are not ideal; they have finite input resistance R_m that loads the circuit and can pull the measured node down. Engineers use a simple criterion to judge whether this loading is negligible: the 10× rule of thumb.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Voltmeter modeled as R_m in parallel with the circuit resistance across which you are measuring.
- Quasi-DC or slow AC measurement where reactive effects are minimal.
- The goal is to keep measurement error small (a few percent or less).
Concept / Approach:When you connect a meter across a resistor R_x, the effective resistance becomes R_eff = (R_x * R_m) / (R_x + R_m). If R_m ≫ R_x, then R_eff ≈ R_x and the circuit is barely disturbed. A common practical threshold is R_m ≥ 10 * R_x, which keeps loading error typically under about 10% and often much less in practice, especially with modern DMMs (10 MΩ inputs).
Step-by-Step Solution:
Model the meter as a parallel resistance R_m.Compute R_eff = (R_x * R_m) / (R_x + R_m).If R_m ≥ 10 * R_x, then R_eff ≈ (R_x * 10R_x) / (11R_x) ≈ 0.909 * R_x, a small perturbation.Conclude loading is negligible at the 10× threshold or higher.Verification / Alternative check:Example: R_x = 100 kΩ; DMM input R_m = 10 MΩ (100×). The equivalent is ~99.01 kΩ, producing <1% error in most divider readings — negligible for many applications.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Very high/very low measured voltage: Voltage magnitude is not the key; the resistance ratio is.
- Meter resistance 10× less than R_x: That heavily loads the node and severely skews the reading.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing meter range with input resistance; some analog meters have low input resistance on low-voltage ranges, causing significant loading errors on high-impedance circuits.
Final Answer:Use the 10× rule — R_m should be at least 10 times R_x to ignore loading.