Effect of section modulus on bending stress If the section modulus Z of a beam is increased while bending moment M remains the same, how will the maximum bending stress change?

Mechanical Engineering Strength of Materials Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    not change
  • B
    increase
  • C
    decrease
  • D
    become zero
  • E
    reverse sign only

Answer

Correct Answer: decrease

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Beam design frequently leverages the relationship σ = M / Z. Increasing section modulus by changing cross-section shape or size is a primary strategy to cut bending stress for a given moment.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Bending moment M is fixed by loading and span.
  • Section modulus Z is altered via geometry (e.g., larger depth, flanges).
  • Linear elastic bending; plane sections remain plane.

Concept / Approach:Maximum bending stress in elastic range is σ_max = M / Z. This is an inverse proportionality: higher Z means lower σ for the same M.

Step-by-Step Solution:Start with σ = M / Z.Increase Z → denominator increases.Therefore σ decreases proportionally.No sign change occurs; stress nature (tension/compression) is set by loading, not Z.

Verification / Alternative check:Example: if Z doubles, σ halves. This is why I-sections (large Z for given area) are efficient for bending resistance.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Not change: contradicts σ = M / Z. Increase: opposite of the formula. Become zero or reverse sign: impossible without changing M or load sense.

Common Pitfalls:Confusing section modulus Z with second moment I; Z = I / c, so increasing depth c while adjusting I is key to stress reduction.

Final Answer:decrease

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion