Open-channel hydraulics — circular channel condition for maxima For a circular open channel, when the hydraulic mean depth Dm equals 0.30 D (D = diameter), this condition corresponds to the maximum of which quantity?
-
Aflow rate
-
Bmean velocity
-
Cboth 'a' & 'b'
-
Dneither 'a' nor 'b'
Answer
Correct Answer: flow rate
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Design of circular open channels (partially full pipes, sewers) often uses optimal depth conditions for maximum discharge or maximum velocity. Hydraulic mean depth Dm = A/P (area over wetted perimeter) is a convenient parameter. This question targets the specific condition Dm = 0.30 D.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Circular channel partially full (open-channel flow).
- D = full pipe diameter; Dm = A/P.
- Known hydraulic optima exist for max discharge and max velocity.
Concept / Approach:For a circular channel: maximum discharge (flow rate) occurs at a depth close to 0.94–0.96 D, for which hydraulic mean depth is about 0.29–0.30 D. Maximum mean velocity occurs at a shallower depth (roughly 0.80–0.82 D), corresponding to Dm about 0.24–0.25 D. Therefore, Dm = 0.30 D signals the maximum discharge condition, not the maximum velocity condition.
Step-by-Step Solution:Recall optimums: Dm ≈ 0.30 D → max discharge; Dm ≈ 0.25 D → max velocity.Match the given Dm to the appropriate maximum.Select “flow rate.”
Verification / Alternative check:Derivations from Manning or Chezy formulations with geometric relations for circular segments confirm the distinct depths for maxima.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Mean velocity: associated with Dm ≈ 0.25 D, not 0.30 D.
- Both/neither: contradict standard geometric-hydraulic results.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming maxima for velocity and discharge occur at the same depth—they do not.
Final Answer:flow rate