Directions: Read the following information carefully and answer the questions that follow: A train journey from P to D by an X-express has 4 classes of fares | Class | Fare | Berths per bogie | Train Composition | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | 3 tier | ₹ 300 | 72 berths per bogie | Train has 8 bogies | | AC-3 tier | ₹ 898 | 64 berths per bogie | Train has 2 bogies | | AC-2 tier | ₹ 1388 | 45 berths per bogie | Train has 2 bogies | | AC-first class | ₹ 2691 | 26 berths per bogie | Train has 1 bogie | The distance between P and D is 1100 km. Assume that the train does not stop at any station unless otherwise indicated. The running cost per kilometre: AC - bogie – ₹ 25, non-AC-bogie – ₹ 10 The highest revenue for a journey from P to D will always be generated by
Aptitude
Profit and Loss
Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
-
AAC- 2 tier
-
B3 tier
-
CAC-3 tier
-
DCannot be determined
Answer
Correct Answer: Cannot be determined
Explanation
### Concept & Logical Deduction
Total revenue depends on both the ticket price (fare), total capacity, and the actual occupancy rate on a given day.
$$\text{Revenue} = \text{Fare} \times \text{Occupied Berths}$$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* If we assume **full occupancy**, the revenues generated are:
* 3 tier: ₹ 1,72,800
* AC-2 tier: ₹ 1,24,920
* AC-3 tier: ₹ 1,14,944
* AC-first class: ₹ 69,966
* Under full occupancy, 3 tier generates the highest revenue.
* However, the question states "will **always** be generated by".
* Because the problem does not guarantee fixed occupancy rates (e.g., the 3-tier bogies might be completely empty while the AC bogies are full), revenue generation is variable.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Whenever a question uses absolute qualifiers like "always" regarding a metric that relies on variable inputs (like passenger occupancy), the answer is almost always "Cannot be determined" unless the minimum threshold of one exceeds the maximum of all others.
### Common Pitfall
Students often calculate maximum potential revenue, see that 3-tier is the highest, and mistakenly select it, missing the crucial qualifying word "always".
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **Cannot be determined**.