In the following question, one part of the sentence may have an error. Find out which part of the sentence has an error and select the appropriate option; if the sentence is free from error, select "No Error". The job for drawing water from the village well is usually carried out by the women and young girls.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: A

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This error spotting question examines your understanding of correct prepositional use in English, particularly the distinction between "job of" and "job for." The sentence describes a routine task in a village and asks you to identify which underlined segment contains a grammatical or idiomatic error.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Full sentence: The job for drawing water (A) from the village well is usually (B) carried out by the women and young girls. (C) No Error (D)
  • Part A: "The job for drawing water"
  • Part B: "from the village well is usually"
  • Part C: "carried out by the women and young girls."
  • Part D: No Error option.


Concept / Approach:
In idiomatic English, when we describe the kind of work or duty someone has, we usually say "the job of doing something," not "the job for doing something." For example, "the job of cleaning the room," "the job of organising the files." The preposition "for" is used differently, such as in "the job is for you." So the error is in the phrase "job for drawing water," which should be "job of drawing water."


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Examine part A: "The job for drawing water." Step 2: Recall the standard pattern: "the job of drawing water." Step 3: Identify that the preposition "for" is incorrect here and should be replaced by "of." Step 4: Check parts B and C and see that they are grammatically correct: "from the village well is usually carried out by the women and young girls." Step 5: Conclude that the error lies in part A.


Verification / Alternative check:
Rewrite the corrected sentence to verify: "The job of drawing water from the village well is usually carried out by the women and young girls." This version sounds natural and idiomatic, which confirms that part A was the only defective segment. Parts B and C follow correct structure and use appropriate prepositions and verb forms.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • B: "from the village well is usually" is correct, as "from" correctly indicates the source of the water and "is usually" is a proper verb phrase for a habitual action.
  • C: "carried out by the women and young girls" is grammatically and idiomatically correct passive construction.
  • D: "No Error" cannot be chosen because there is a definite prepositional error in part A.


Common Pitfalls:
Students often overlook small preposition errors, especially when the overall meaning of the sentence is clear. They may accept "job for" as natural because "for" is a very common word. To avoid such mistakes, pay special attention to fixed phrases like "the task of," "the duty of," or "the job of," which consistently take the preposition "of" before a gerund.


Final Answer:
The part of the sentence that contains an error is A, because the correct phrase should be "The job of drawing water."

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion