Antibody production against mouse MHC I — To elicit strong anti-mouse MHC I antibodies, into which animal should the antigen be injected?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: goat

Explanation:


Introduction:
Robust antibody generation depends on perceiving the antigen as foreign. This question asks which host species would best recognize mouse MHC class I proteins as foreign and mount a strong antibody response.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Antigen: mouse MHC I proteins.
  • Goal: maximize immunogenicity for polyclonal antibody production.
  • Common laboratory host choices: same species/strain, different strain, or different species.


Concept / Approach:
Greater phylogenetic distance usually increases immunogenicity for conserved proteins. Injecting mouse MHC I into another species (e.g., goat, rabbit) typically yields stronger, broader antibody responses than injecting into mice. Injecting into the same strain can result in tolerance; even different strains may respond weakly due to shared homology compared with another species.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1) Same strain mouse: self antigen → immunological tolerance; minimal response.2) Different strain mouse: allotype differences can induce response, but homology limits breadth.3) Different species (goat, rabbit, rat): more foreign → stronger response; larger hosts like goats are commonly used for high-yield polyclonals.4) Choose a well-established heterologous host: goat.


Verification / Alternative check:
Antibody production services routinely use goats or rabbits to raise high-titer polyclonal antibodies against mouse proteins, reflecting practical immunogenicity advantages.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Same-strain mouse: tolerance prevents strong responses.
  • Different-strain mouse: response possible but weaker than cross-species.
  • Rat: heterologous and workable, but goats typically produce higher yields and strong titers; the question asks for the best option among those listed.
  • Rabbit: also good; among given choices, goat is at least as good or better in yield; only one answer is allowed.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming any non-self will be equally immunogenic. Host size, phylogenetic distance, and husbandry considerations affect titer and yield.


Final Answer:
goat.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion