Ohm’s law proportionality — voltage vs. current: Doubling the voltage across a fixed resistor will cut the current by half. Evaluate this statement for a linear (ohmic) resistor.
-
ACorrect
-
BIncorrect
-
COnly correct for non-ohmic devices
-
DCorrect only if temperature rises
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Ohm’s law is the foundational relationship between voltage, current, and resistance: V = I * R. Misstatements about proportionality are common in quick reasoning under pressure. This question tests whether doubling the applied voltage across a fixed, linear resistor halves the current, doubles it, or does something else.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Resistor is linear (ohmic) over the operating range.
- Resistance R is constant with voltage in the scenario.
- Ambient and self-heating effects are negligible for the concept check.
Concept / Approach:From I = V / R, holding R constant means current is directly proportional to voltage. If V is doubled, I must also double, not be halved. The statement in the stem therefore contradicts Ohm’s law for an ohmic resistor. Non-ohmic devices (lamps, diodes) may not follow V/I linearity, but they are not “resistors” in the ideal Ohm’s law sense posed by the question.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Start with I1 = V1 / R.Double the voltage: V2 = 2 * V1 while R is unchanged.Compute I2 = V2 / R = (2 * V1) / R = 2 * (V1 / R) = 2 * I1.Conclude that current doubles when voltage doubles across a fixed resistor.Verification / Alternative check:Graphing the I–V curve of a resistor gives a straight line through the origin with slope 1/R. Doubling V moves you to a point with twice the current on the same line—consistent with the direct proportionality.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Correct: Not correct; the correct behavior is doubling, not halving.
- Only correct for non-ohmic devices: The question states “resistor”; non-ohmic devices are outside scope.
- Correct only if temperature rises: Temperature coefficients can change R slightly but not invert proportionality to make current half for doubled voltage.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing series/parallel changes in R with changes in applied V; attributing non-linear device behavior to ideal resistors.
Final Answer:Incorrect.