In fluid mechanics, for a totally submerged orifice discharging between two reservoirs, the discharge Q is directly proportional to which head measure? (Assume steady flow, sharp-edged orifice, and fully submerged upstream and downstream openings.)

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Square root of the difference in elevation of water surfaces

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
An orifice is an opening in a wall or plate through which fluid flows. When both the upstream and downstream openings are submerged, it is a totally submerged (drowned) orifice. Understanding how discharge depends on head is a core hydrostatics–hydrodynamics concept used in tanks, gates, and culverts.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Steady, incompressible flow of water.
  • Sharp-edged orifice with coefficient of discharge Cd approximately constant in the considered range.
  • Both sides submerged; head driving flow is the difference in water surface elevations (ΔH).


Concept / Approach:

From Bernoulli and continuity, the theoretical discharge through an orifice is Q_th = A * √(2 * g * ΔH), where A is the orifice area, g is gravitational acceleration, and ΔH is the difference in piezometric head. Real discharge is Q = Cd * A * √(2 * g * ΔH). Hence, for fixed A and Cd, Q varies with the square root of ΔH, not linearly with ΔH.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify the driving head for a drowned orifice: ΔH = H_up − H_down.Write discharge: Q = Cd * A * √(2 * g * ΔH).Conclude proportionality: Q ∝ √(ΔH) for constant Cd and A.


Verification / Alternative check:

Dimensional check: √(g * ΔH) has dimensions of velocity. Multiplying by area A gives volume flow per unit time—consistent with discharge units.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

(a) Linear proportionality to ΔH is incorrect; the dependence is on the square root. (c) “Square root of the opening” is dimensionally inconsistent. (d) Reciprocal area contradicts continuity; Q increases with area. (e) is unnecessary since (b) is correct.


Common Pitfalls:

Confusing free orifice head (to atmosphere) with submerged head difference; assuming linear dependence on head without checking Bernoulli-based velocity relation.


Final Answer:

Square root of the difference in elevation of water surfaces

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion