Point D is in which direction with respect to point B? I. A is to the West of B; C is to the North of D; D is to the South of C. II. G is to the South of D; BG = 4 m; BD = 9 m. III. A is to the West of B; B is exactly midway between A and E; F is to the South of E; D is to the West of F.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: If statements I and III are sufficient while II is not required.

Explanation:

Introduction / Context:We need the relative direction of D from B. In 2D direction questions, qualitative cardinal relations (north/south/east/west) often suffice without exact distances, as long as reference points connect B to D through consistent geometry.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • I: A west of B; C north of D; D south of C (so C directly north of D). This links D and C but not yet to B.
  • II: G south of D with distances BG = 4 m and BD = 9 m. Distance data involving G does not directly fix compass direction unless G’s bearing is tied to B.
  • III: A west of B; B is midpoint of AE; F south of E; D west of F. This ties D to E/F and E to B (through midpoint relation).

Concept / Approach:Combine statements that connect B–A–E–F–D to infer D’s bearing from B. Distances to G are extraneous unless they yield bearings, which they do not here.

Step-by-Step Solution:From III: With B the midpoint of AE and A west of B, E must be east of B on the same horizontal line. Since F is south of E and D is west of F, D is somewhere southwest of E; relative to B (which is west of E), D ends up to the south and (typically) east/west depending on the offset.Use I to orient vertical relation: C north of D and A west of B. With A already west of B from III, the composite of I + III places D to the south relative to C while keeping the AE baseline horizontal through B. The construction constrains D to be south-west of B (west via “D west of F” and south via “F south of E,” with E east of B).Thus I + III together determine a fixed quadrant for D from B (south-west). Statement II adds a distance to an unrelated point G and does not refine the quadrant.

Verification / Alternative check:Sketching consistent placements shows D must lie to the south-west of B using I + III; varying II does not change the direction.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:I alone lacks linkage from D to B; III alone could allow ambiguous quadrants without the north/south tie from I; II is unnecessary.

Common Pitfalls:Overvaluing raw distances without bearings; direction questions usually rely on relative placements.

Final Answer:Statements I and III are sufficient; II is not required.

More Questions from Data Sufficiency

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion