Change the following sentence from direct to indirect speech: The teacher said, "The Earth revolves around the sun."

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: The teacher said that the Earth revolves around the sun.

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:

This question tests your knowledge of direct and indirect speech, especially for sentences containing universal truths or scientific facts. The original sentence is a statement by a teacher about the movement of the Earth around the sun. In reported speech, the tense of a universal truth generally remains unchanged because the fact is still true at the time of reporting.


Given Data / Assumptions:

- Direct speech: The teacher said, "The Earth revolves around the sun." - Reporting verb: said, in simple past tense. - Reported clause: The Earth revolves around the sun. - This clause expresses a scientific fact that is always true.


Concept / Approach:

In indirect speech, if the original statement expresses a universal truth, habitual action, or general fact, we usually do not change the tense of the verb in the reported clause. Although the reporting verb said is in past tense, the verb revolves remains in simple present because the Earth still revolves around the sun today. The structure becomes The teacher said that plus unchanged fact. Any form like revolved or had been revolving would wrongly suggest a change in the nature or time of the fact.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1. Remove the quotation marks and insert the conjunction that after the reporting verb said. 2. Keep the subject The Earth unchanged, because there is no need to alter the subject in this case. 3. Identify the verb revolves as a simple present tense expressing scientific truth. 4. Apply the rule for universal truths in reported speech, which says that we do not backshift the tense. 5. Construct the indirect sentence as The teacher said that the Earth revolves around the sun. 6. Check each option: option B matches this structure exactly.


Verification / Alternative check:

Test what happens if you change the tense. If you say The teacher said that the Earth revolved around the sun, the sentence sounds as if the fact might no longer be true, which is incorrect for a universal truth. Similarly, The teacher said that the Earth had been revolving around the sun suggests a focus on an action continuing in the past rather than a timeless fact. The form is being revolving is ungrammatical. Therefore, keeping revolves is the only option that accurately preserves meaning and correctness.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

The teacher said that the Earth is being revolving around the sun: Grammatically wrong, because is being revolving wrongly combines continuous and progressive structures. The teacher said that the Earth revolved around the sun: Suggests that the revolving might be a past action rather than an ongoing scientific fact. The teacher said that the Earth had been revolving around the sun: Implies a past continuous action up to a certain point, not a statement of permanent truth.


Common Pitfalls:

Students often apply a mechanical rule that simple present becomes simple past whenever the reporting verb is in past tense. This is not true for universal truths and habitual facts. When a sentence expresses something that does not change with time, such as two and two make four or the sun rises in the east, the tense of the reported clause remains in simple present in indirect speech. Always consider the meaning before changing tenses.


Final Answer:

The correct indirect speech is The teacher said that the Earth revolves around the sun.

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion