Conceptually, how does the four-layer DoD (TCP/IP) model differ from the seven-layer OSI model in terms of layer grouping and typical protocol placement?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: The DoD model has four layers that combine OSI upper layers into a single Application layer and merge the lower layers into a Network Access layer, while the OSI model separates functions into seven distinct layers with more granular roles

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The DoD (TCP/IP) model and the OSI model are both conceptual frameworks used to describe how network protocols interact. Cisco exams expect you to understand both models and how they relate. This question asks you to explain the main conceptual difference between the two.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The OSI model defines seven layers: Physical, Data Link, Network, Transport, Session, Presentation, and Application.
  • The DoD model defines four layers: Network Access, Internet, Host-to-Host, and Application.
  • Both models can be used to map real protocols such as Ethernet, IP, TCP, HTTP, and others.


Concept / Approach:
The OSI model is more granular, splitting functionality into seven layers, especially distinguishing between Session, Presentation, and Application at the top and between Physical and Data Link at the bottom. The DoD model reflects practical TCP/IP implementations by grouping several OSI layers together. In the DoD model, the Application layer covers what OSI calls Application, Presentation, and Session. The Host-to-Host layer corresponds roughly to OSI Transport. The Internet layer corresponds to OSI Network. The Network Access layer groups the OSI Data Link and Physical layers into one.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify that the DoD Application layer includes application protocols (HTTP, FTP, SMTP), as well as data representation and session management functions that OSI separates into three layers.Step 2: Recognize that the DoD Host-to-Host layer is where TCP and UDP operate, providing transport services similar to OSI Layer 4.Step 3: Note that the DoD Internet layer contains IP and routing protocols and corresponds to the OSI Network layer.Step 4: See that the DoD Network Access layer handles both physical media and data link framing, which OSI divides into the Physical and Data Link layers.Step 5: Conclude that the main difference is the grouping of functions into four broader layers versus seven more detailed layers.


Verification / Alternative check:
Standard mapping diagrams in textbooks show OSI layers 5 to 7 collapsing into the DoD Application layer and OSI layers 1 and 2 collapsing into the Network Access layer. This visual comparison supports the explanation that the DoD model is a simplified, implementation oriented view of the same stack.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option B is incorrect because the DoD model has fewer layers than OSI and is widely used in real networks; OSI is largely a teaching model.Option C incorrectly claims that OSI is obsolete; while TCP/IP is dominant, OSI remains valuable as a conceptual reference.Option D is wrong because the models clearly use different names and layer boundaries.


Common Pitfalls:
Learners sometimes attempt to memorize both models without understanding the mapping, leading to confusion. Focusing on how OSI layers collapse into the more compact DoD model makes it easier to recall and apply both frameworks in exam scenarios.


Final Answer:
The key difference is that The DoD model has four layers that combine OSI upper layers into a single Application layer and merge the lower layers into a Network Access layer, while the OSI model separates functions into seven distinct layers with more granular roles.

More Questions from CISCO Certification

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion