Which option best describes a disadvantage (or cost) associated with database replication across sites?
-
AReduced network traffic
-
BIf the database fails at one site, a copy can be located at another site.
-
CEach site must have the same storage capacity.
-
DEach transaction may proceed without coordination across the network.
Answer
Correct Answer: Each site must have the same storage capacity.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Replication provides benefits—availability, local read performance, and fault tolerance—but also introduces costs such as additional storage, administrative overhead, and potential consistency challenges.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Replicas consume storage at multiple sites.
- Network coordination can be reduced for reads but still required for writes depending on model.
- The question frames one option as a disadvantage related to capacity.
Concept / Approach:While strict equality of storage capacity is not a hard requirement in all systems, the downside captured by Option C reflects a practical cost: maintaining replicated copies increases storage demands across sites. In many exam contexts, this is presented as “every site must provision substantial storage for replicated data,” which is a disadvantage relative to a single copy.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify advantages: reduced network latency for reads; failover; local execution.Contrast with a storage-related burden across sites.Select the option highlighting the storage disadvantage.Verification / Alternative check:Operational experience shows storage and administrative overheads scale with the number of replicas; capacity planning becomes more complex.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- A: reduced network traffic for read-heavy workloads is an advantage, not a disadvantage.
- B: having a copy at another site is high availability (advantage).
- D: local autonomy (fewer coordinated transactions) is considered an advantage for performance and availability.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming replication is “free” aside from setup; it impacts storage, write coordination, and conflict resolution.
Final Answer:Each site must have the same storage capacity.