For an unconfined (water-table) tube well discharging Q with drawdown s through a screen (strainer) of length L and well radius r_w, with radius of influence R, which expression gives the required screen length in terms of aquifer hydraulic conductivity K?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: L = (Q / (2 * pi * K * s)) * ln(R / r_w)

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Design of unconfined tube wells requires selecting an adequate screen length to safely pass the target discharge at the allowable drawdown. This uses steady radial-flow relations (Thiem equation) adapted to water-table conditions and distributed inflow along the screen length.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Unconfined aquifer with hydraulic conductivity K.
  • Well radius r_w and radius of influence R (R >> r_w).
  • Steady discharge Q with drawdown s at the well under design pumping.
  • Uniform inflow along screen length L (first-approximation design).


Concept / Approach:
For unconfined flow, the Thiem relation connects discharge to head difference and geometry. Spreading the inflow over the screen length gives an average entrance flux. Rearrangement provides the screen length L necessary to limit entrance flux so that the overall drawdown is s for discharge Q. The commonly used expression is:
L = (Q / (2 * pi * K * s)) * ln(R / r_w)
with natural logarithm ln().


Step-by-Step Solution:

Start with steady radial flow for unconfined conditions and distribute inflow over L.Relate Q, K, s, and log term ln(R / r_w) from Thiem.Solve for L to obtain: L = (Q / (2 * pi * K * s)) * ln(R / r_w).


Verification / Alternative check:
Dimensional check: Q has L^3/T; denominator 2 * pi * K * s is L/T; multiplying by the dimensionless ln term yields L (length), as required.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Options with inverted fraction or missing 2 * pi lead to incorrect scaling.
  • Replacing ln(R / r_w) with (R / r_w) is incorrect; radial flow solution yields the logarithmic term.


Common Pitfalls:

  • Using confined-aquifer formulas directly without adapting to water-table conditions.
  • Forgetting the logarithmic dependence on R / r_w.


Final Answer:
L = (Q / (2 * pi * K * s)) * ln(R / r_w)

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion