More Questions from Waste Water Engineering

For computing mean velocity of flow in sanitary sewers with known slope and roughness, which empirical relation is most widely used in modern practice?

Civil Engineering Waste Water Engineering Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    Manning's formula
  • B
    Kutter's formula
  • C
    Chezy's formula
  • D
    Bazin's formula
  • E
    Williams–Hazen formula

Answer

Correct Answer: Manning's formula

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Hydraulic design of gravity sewers requires a reliable formula linking velocity, hydraulic radius, slope, and roughness. Among several historical relations, one has become the de facto standard in sewer design manuals.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Open-channel (partially full) or full-flow gravity conditions.
  • Steady, uniform flow assumption for sizing.
  • Use of a roughness parameter calibrated for pipe material.

Concept / Approach:Manning's formula expresses velocity as V = (1/n) * R^(2/3) * S^(1/2), where n is Manning's roughness coefficient, R is hydraulic radius, and S is slope of energy grade line. It is simple, dimensionally consistent in SI, and supported by abundant tabulations of n for sewer materials.

Step-by-Step Solution:Identify the design need: mean velocity under steady, uniform flow.Select formula with widely available roughness data: Manning's.Apply for partial flow by using actual wetted area and perimeter to compute R.

Verification / Alternative check:Chezy, Kutter, and Bazin are predecessors and can be interrelated, but modern codes almost universally present charts/tables in terms of Manning's n for pipes and channels.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Chezy/Kutter/Bazin: Historically important but less convenient; require coefficients that vary with R and S.
  • Williams–Hazen: Suited to pressurized water mains; not ideal for open-channel sewer hydraulics.

Common Pitfalls:Using inappropriate n values; forgetting that sediment or slime layers increase effective roughness; applying full-flow hydraulic radius to partial-flow conditions.

Final Answer:Manning's formula

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion