Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: C(18,12) * 11!/2
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
The original stem was ambiguous. Under the Recovery-First Policy, we minimally clarify: pick any 12 distinct beads from 18, then arrange them as a necklace up to rotation and reflection. This yields a clean, teachable count consistent with necklace problems.
Given Data / Assumptions (clarified):
Concept / Approach:
Two stages: (1) choose the multiset of beads; (2) form the necklace quotienting by dihedral symmetry. Choosing 12 distinct beads from 18 gives C(18,12). Arranging 12 distinct beads on a necklace (rotations and reflections identified) gives 11!/2.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Selection count = C(18,12).Necklace count for a 12-bead set = 11!/2.Total designs = C(18,12) * (11!/2).
Verification / Alternative check:
Equivalently: choose 12 and then count circular arrangements divided by 2 for flips; beads are all distinct, so no additional stabilizers arise.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Using 10!/2 or 12!/2 mismodels the circular quotient; “None of these” is incorrect under the clarified reading.
Common Pitfalls:
Forgetting the reflection factor 1/2, or treating the 12-bead selection as ordered.
Final Answer:
C(18,12) * 11!/2
Discussion & Comments