From 18 distinct coloured beads, necklaces of length 12 are to be made. Each necklace uses 12 distinct beads selected from the 18. Considering rotation and reflection as the same design, how many distinct necklaces are possible?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: C(18,12) * 11!/2

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The original stem was ambiguous. Under the Recovery-First Policy, we minimally clarify: pick any 12 distinct beads from 18, then arrange them as a necklace up to rotation and reflection. This yields a clean, teachable count consistent with necklace problems.



Given Data / Assumptions (clarified):

  • 18 distinct beads available.
  • Each necklace uses 12 distinct beads.
  • Designs equivalent under rotation and mirror reflection.


Concept / Approach:
Two stages: (1) choose the multiset of beads; (2) form the necklace quotienting by dihedral symmetry. Choosing 12 distinct beads from 18 gives C(18,12). Arranging 12 distinct beads on a necklace (rotations and reflections identified) gives 11!/2.



Step-by-Step Solution:
Selection count = C(18,12).Necklace count for a 12-bead set = 11!/2.Total designs = C(18,12) * (11!/2).



Verification / Alternative check:
Equivalently: choose 12 and then count circular arrangements divided by 2 for flips; beads are all distinct, so no additional stabilizers arise.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Using 10!/2 or 12!/2 mismodels the circular quotient; “None of these” is incorrect under the clarified reading.



Common Pitfalls:
Forgetting the reflection factor 1/2, or treating the 12-bead selection as ordered.



Final Answer:
C(18,12) * 11!/2

More Questions from Permutation and Combination

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion