Why are cast iron (C.I.) pipes commonly preferred in water-supply distribution systems? Select the most appropriate reason from the choices given.
-
AThey are moderately priced compared to many pressure-rated alternatives
-
BThey are easy to joint (lead-caulked, rubber-gasketed, or mechanical joints)
-
CThey offer good durability and service life against internal pressure and external loads
-
DThey generally achieve a longer life in buried service with proper corrosion protection
-
EAll of the above
Answer
Correct Answer: All of the above
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Choosing a pipe material for municipal distribution involves balancing cost, ease of installation, and long-term performance. Cast iron (historically) and ductile iron (modern successor) have been widely used for pressurized buried mains due to their structural robustness and reliable joints.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Buried, pressurized water-distribution environment.
- Standard jointing methods (e.g., spigot-and-socket with gaskets/mechanical joints).
- Corrosion protection (e.g., lining, coatings) is provided as per practice.
Concept / Approach:The selection criteria include capital cost, joint reliability, internal pressure capacity, external load resistance (traffic/surcharge), and expected service life. Cast iron has historically met these requirements, which explains its prevalence in legacy networks and its continued relevance via ductile iron.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Compare materials on cost: C.I. mains are traditionally moderate in capital cost for pressure duty.Assess constructability: standardized joints make installation straightforward.Evaluate durability: wall thickness and stiffness resist internal pressure and external loads.Consider life cycle: with lining/coatings and soil-side protection, long life is achievable.Verification / Alternative check:Many cities with century-old C.I. networks still have segments in service, underscoring longevity when protected from corrosion and surge.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Options (a)–(d) each highlight a true advantage; focusing on only one misses the full picture.
- Therefore the comprehensive choice is (e) All of the above.
Common Pitfalls:Ignoring the need for corrosion control; any ferrous pipe without proper protection may suffer premature deterioration.
Final Answer:All of the above