Directions: Each of the questions given below consists of a question followed by three statements. You have to study the question and the statements and decide which of the statement(s) is/are necessary to answer the question. What is the capacity of the cylindrical tank? I. The area of the base is 61,600 sq. cm. II. The height of the tank is 1.5 times the radius. III. The circumference of base is 880 cm.
Verbal Reasoning
Data Sufficiency
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
AOnly I and II
-
BOnly II and III
-
COnly I and III
-
DAny two of the three
-
EOnly II and either I or III
Answer
Correct Answer: Only II and either I or III
Explanation
### Concept & Logic
To find the capacity (volume) of a cylindrical tank, we need its radius ($r$) and height ($h$). The formula is:
$$ \text{Volume} = \pi r^2 h $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
- **Statement I:** Gives the area of the base ($\pi r^2 = 61600$). From this, we can find the radius $r$. However, height $h$ is still unknown. So, Statement I alone is insufficient.
- **Statement II:** Gives the relationship $h = 1.5r$. We still need the value of $r$ or $h$ to find the volume. So, Statement II alone is insufficient.
- **Statement III:** Gives the circumference of the base ($2\pi r = 880$). From this, we can find the radius $r$. However, height $h$ is still unknown. So, Statement III alone is insufficient.
- **Combining Statements:**
- **I and II:** From I, we get $r$. From II, we can find $h$ using $r$. Thus, we can find the volume. (Sufficient)
- **III and II:** From III, we get $r$. From II, we can find $h$ using $r$. Thus, we can find the volume. (Sufficient)
- **I and III:** Both only give us the radius $r$. We still don't know the height $h$. (Insufficient)
- Therefore, we need Statement II and either Statement I or Statement III.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
In Data Sufficiency, you do not need to calculate the final answer. Just identify the variables required. Here, you need $r$ and $h$. Statements I and III both provide ways to find $r$. Statement II provides the link between $r$ and $h$. Thus, pairing II with either I or III will give both necessary variables.
### Common Pitfall
A common mistake is thinking that combining I and III might yield new information, but they both represent the same geometrical parameter (the base) and are redundant when used together.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **Only II and either I or III**.