Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: The program incorrectly assigns the result of a void function f() to the int variable a
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question focuses on function return types in C and on how void functions are intended to be used. It checks whether the learner understands that a void function does not return a value, and therefore its result cannot be assigned to a variable or used in expressions. Recognising this kind of error is important for reading and writing correct C code, and it is a common source of compiler diagnostics for beginners.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- The function f is declared as void f(); meaning it does not return any value.
- Inside main, the integer variable a is initialised to 10 and then reassigned using a = f();
- The program calls printf to display the value of a after the call to f.
- We assume that required headers such as stdio.h would be included in a complete program, and we focus here on the logical and type correctness of the code.
Concept / Approach:
In C, every function has a declared return type. A function with return type void does not produce a value that can be used in expressions. It is legal to call such a function as a standalone statement, but it is illegal to attempt to assign its result to a variable. The compiler enforces this by issuing an error when code tries to treat the result of a void function as a value. The correct approach is either to give the function a nonvoid return type and return a value explicitly, or to call the void function without assignment if no value is needed.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1. Read the forward declaration void f();, which states that f takes no parameters (in modern style) and does not return any value.
2. Inside main, the code a = f(); attempts to call f and assign its result to the integer variable a.
3. Since f is void, there is no result value. The C type system does not allow converting a void expression into int in this way.
4. Most compilers will issue an error message such as void value not ignored as it ought to be, or a similar diagnostic.
5. To fix the program, either change the declaration and definition of f to return an int and add an appropriate return statement, or remove the assignment and simply call f(); without using its result.
6. For example, if the intent is just to print Hi and leave a unchanged, write f(); and then printf("%d", a);.
Verification / Alternative check:
If you compile a version of this code with a modern C compiler, you will see an error generated for the assignment of the void expression f() to a. Modifying f so that it returns an int, for example int f(void) { printf("Hi"); return 20; }, and then adjusting the declaration to int f(void); will remove this error. Alternatively, simply calling f(); without using its non-existent result also compiles. These checks confirm that the core problem is the illegal use of a void function in an assignment expression.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option B is incorrect because there is no requirement that f be static; storage class keywords do not fix the return type problem. Option C is irrelevant to the specific error; while modern C standards require main to return int, that is not what prevents compilation in the given snippet. Option D is false because printf can be called inside any function body, including void functions, as long as stdio.h is included and the call is correct. Only option A correctly identifies that the program tries to assign the result of a void function to an int variable, which is not allowed.
Common Pitfalls:
Many beginners confuse returning from a function with printing from a function. They sometimes think that printing a value also counts as returning a value that can be used outside the function. Another common mistake is to ignore the declared return type and assume that any function can be used in expressions. This question emphasises the distinction between a function that returns a useful result and one that performs actions only. Paying attention to function prototypes and compiler diagnostics is essential in avoiding these issues.
Final Answer:
The error is that the program assigns the result of a void function to an int variable. The call should not be used in an assignment, or the function should be given a proper nonvoid return type. The correct choice is the program incorrectly assigns the result of a void function f() to the int variable a.
Discussion & Comments