Directions: These questions are based on the following information: Given that $a : b = 5 : 3$ and $b : c = 2 : 5$. $(c - a)$ will be equal to I. $10(a + c)$ II. $10a + 25b$
Aptitude
Ratio and Proportion
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
AOnly I is true
-
BOnly II is true
-
CBoth I and II are true
-
DBoth I and II are false
Answer
Correct Answer: Both I and II are false
Explanation
### Concept & Algebraic Evaluation of Ratios
To determine if statements regarding variables in a ratio are true, express all variables in terms of a single proportionality constant ($k$) and substitute them into the given algebraic expressions to test for equivalence.
### Step-by-Step Solution
1. **Given:** The combined continuous ratio is $a : b : c = 10 : 6 : 15$.
2. Let the values be represented as $a = 10k$, $b = 6k$, and $c = 15k$.
3. First, evaluate the target expression $(c - a)$:
$$(c - a) = 15k - 10k = 5k$$
4. Now, evaluate Statement I: $10(a + c)$
$$10(10k + 15k) = 10(25k) = 250k$$
Since $5k \neq 250k$, Statement I is not equal to $(c - a)$. It is false.
5. Evaluate Statement II: $10a + 25b$
$$10(10k) + 25(6k) = 100k + 150k = 250k$$
Since $5k \neq 250k$, Statement II is also not equal to $(c - a)$. It is false.
6. Because neither algebraic statement evaluates to $5k$, both are false.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Test logic using the simplest integers. Let $a=10, b=6, c=15$. The target $(c-a)$ equals $5$. Statement I is $10(10+15) = 250$. Statement II is $10(10) + 25(6) = 100 + 150 = 250$. Since $5 \neq 250$, both are demonstrably false.
### Common Pitfall
A student might notice that Statement I ($250k$) and Statement II ($250k$) are mathematically equal to each other and mistakenly select "Both I and II are true", forgetting that the question specifically asks if they are equal to the initial expression $(c - a)$.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **Both I and II are false**.