Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: India
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question concerns comparative birth rates in five countries. You are not given exact numerical birth rates, but only relative information such as higher than and lower than. The task is to determine which country has the highest birth rate among India, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Pakistan. This type of conceptual ordering problem is common in reasoning tests and helps assess how well you can work with chains of inequalities.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Countries considered: India, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Pakistan.
- Birth rate in Nepal is the lowest among all five countries.
- Birth rate in Pakistan is higher than that in Sri Lanka but lower than that in India.
- Birth rate in Bangladesh is higher than that in Nepal but lower than that in Sri Lanka.
- All birth rates are distinct and comparable.
Concept / Approach:
To solve this, we convert each statement into an inequality, using greater than to mean higher birth rate. The information about Pakistan places it between Sri Lanka and India. The information about Bangladesh places it between Nepal and Sri Lanka. Knowing that Nepal is lowest sets the baseline. Combining all inequalities in a consistent order allows us to see which country must be at the top with the highest birth rate. We do not need exact values; only the relative chain matters.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: From Nepal has the lowest birth rate, we know every other country has a higher birth rate than Nepal.
Step 2: From Pakistan is higher than Sri Lanka but lower than India, we write India > Pakistan > Sri Lanka.
Step 3: From Bangladesh is higher than Nepal but lower than Sri Lanka, we get Sri Lanka > Bangladesh > Nepal.
Step 4: Combine these chains. We now have India at the top of the partial order, since India is above Pakistan, and Pakistan is above Sri Lanka. Also, Sri Lanka is above Bangladesh, and Bangladesh is above Nepal.
Step 5: The fully consistent order from highest to lowest birth rate is India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Nepal.
Step 6: From this order, India is clearly at the top and therefore has the highest birth rate among the five countries.
Verification / Alternative check:
As a check, you can imagine sample numerical birth rates that satisfy all the inequalities. For example, let India have a birth rate of 30 units, Pakistan 26 units, Sri Lanka 22 units, Bangladesh 18 units and Nepal 12 units. Pakistan (26) is higher than Sri Lanka (22) but lower than India (30), and Bangladesh (18) is higher than Nepal (12) but lower than Sri Lanka (22). Nepal is lowest. In this assignment, India clearly has the highest birth rate. Any other set of numbers that satisfies the same relationships will still position India above all others, confirming our conclusion.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Pakistan cannot have the highest birth rate because it is explicitly stated to be lower than India.
- Sri Lanka is below Pakistan in birth rate, so it also cannot be the highest.
- Bangladesh is lower than Sri Lanka and certainly lower than Pakistan and India, so it is not the highest.
- Nepal is given as the lowest of all five countries, so it definitely cannot be the highest.
Common Pitfalls:
A common mistake is to overlook the statement about Nepal being the lowest and to treat all comparisons as isolated pieces instead of integrating them. Another error is to misread higher than and lower than, inverting the intended order. Some students may be tempted to choose Pakistan because it is mentioned as higher than Sri Lanka, but they forget that it is still lower than India. Writing down the full chain of inequalities in a clear order helps avoid these mistakes.
Final Answer:
The country with the highest birth rate among the five is India.
Discussion & Comments