Zeolite (Ion-Exchange) Softening — The process removes both temporary and permanent hardness. In this method, the calcium and magnesium in water are effectively removed as:
-
AInsoluble carbonates formed in the bulk water
-
BInsoluble zeolites (Ca/Mg form) retained on the ion-exchange matrix
-
CInsoluble chlorides precipitated from solution
-
DInsoluble sulfates precipitated from solution
-
EGaseous by-products that escape
Answer
Correct Answer: Insoluble zeolites (Ca/Mg form) retained on the ion-exchange matrix
Explanation
Introduction:Water hardness arises from dissolved calcium and magnesium salts. The zeolite (also called sodium-zeolite) softening process removes hardness via ion exchange, not by bulk precipitation. Recognizing the correct removal mechanism helps distinguish it from lime–soda softening (a precipitation process).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Sodium-form zeolite (Na-Z) exchanges Na+ for Ca2+/Mg2+ in hard water.
- Process targets both temporary (bicarbonate) and permanent (sulfate/chloride) hardness.
- Regeneration is later accomplished with brine (NaCl) to restore Na-Z.
Concept / Approach:
In ion exchange, calcium and magnesium ions are captured on the solid zeolite matrix as Ca-Z and Mg-Z while sodium ions are released to the water. No insoluble carbonate, sulfate, or chloride precipitates in the bulk solution during this step; instead, the ions are immobilized on the resin/zeolite. Hence, they are “removed as insoluble zeolite forms.”
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write exchange reaction: 2 Na-Z + Ca2+ → Ca-Z + 2 Na+ (analogous for Mg2+).Note that hardness ions leave the solution phase and bind to the solid.Conclude removal occurs by solid-phase capture (insoluble zeolite form), not precipitation as carbonates/sulfates/chlorides.Select the option describing “insoluble zeolites.”Verification / Alternative check:
Operationally, the bed exhausts as exchange sites become Ca/Mg-loaded; regeneration with NaCl brine reverses the reaction, restoring Na-Z and releasing Ca/Mg in the brine waste.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A, C, D: These describe precipitation mechanisms typical of lime–soda treatment, not zeolite exchange. E: No gaseous product removes hardness in this process.
Common Pitfalls:
Assuming all softening involves precipitation. Ion exchange is distinct and often used as a polishing step after clarification/filtration.
Final Answer:
Insoluble zeolites (Ca/Mg form) retained on the ion-exchange matrix