Definition check: Band-stop (notch) filter passband and stopband Does a band-stop filter pass the frequencies within its lower and upper critical frequencies and reject all others, or is it the opposite?
-
AFalse
-
BTrue
-
CTrue only for narrow notches
-
DTrue only for active filters
-
ETrue at very low Q values
Answer
Correct Answer: False
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Filter terminology distinguishes which frequency regions are passed and which are rejected. Confusing band-pass with band-stop leads to design and analysis errors when specifying cutoffs and Q.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Lower critical frequency fL and upper critical frequency fH define the edges of a band.
- Magnitude at critical frequencies is commonly taken at the −3 dB point for first-order sections or appropriately defined for higher order.
- Band-stop (notch) filters reject a band; band-pass filters pass a band.
Concept / Approach:
A band-stop filter attenuates frequencies between fL and fH (the stopband) and passes frequencies below fL and above fH (the passbands). Conversely, a band-pass filter passes frequencies between fL and fH and rejects those well below or above.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Define stopband: fL < f < fH for band-stop.Define passbands: f < fL and f > fH for band-stop.Therefore, the statement that a band-stop “passes between fL and fH” is incorrect; that is the definition of band-pass.Practical realizations may have finite attenuation, but the conceptual classification holds.Verification / Alternative check:
Examine prototype transfer functions: a parallel RLC in series yields a notch at resonance, attenuating frequencies near f0 between fL and fH; outside that band, the response recovers—classic band-stop behavior.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Any version of “True” reverses the definitions.
- Active vs passive or narrow vs wide notch does not flip pass/stop meanings.
Common Pitfalls:
Swapping the roles of band-pass and band-stop because both use two critical frequencies. Always anchor on whether the middle band is passed (band-pass) or rejected (band-stop).
Final Answer:
False