Assertion–Reason on reciprocity and S-parameters Assertion (A): For a reciprocal microwave junction, the scattering matrix S is symmetric. Reason (R): In a symmetric matrix, S_ij = S_ji by definition.
-
ABoth A and R are correct and R is correct explanation of A
-
BBoth A and R are correct but R is not correct explanation of A
-
CA is correct but R is wrong
-
DA is wrong but R is correct
Answer
Correct Answer: Both A and R are correct but R is not correct explanation of A
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Scattering parameters (S-parameters) describe how multiport microwave networks reflect and transmit signals. Reciprocity is a physical property of many passive networks composed of linear, bilateral materials. Understanding how reciprocity constrains the S-matrix is core to network analysis and measurements.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Linear, time-invariant, passive, and bilateral network (no magnetized ferrites or active nonreciprocal elements).
- Standard S-parameter definitions referenced to equal port impedances.
Concept / Approach:For a reciprocal network, the transmission from port i to port j equals that from port j to port i when referenced properly. In matrix form, this implies S = S^T (i.e., S_ij = S_ji), so the S-matrix is symmetric. The reason statement merely defines what a symmetric matrix means; it does not itself link reciprocity to symmetry. Therefore A is true, R is true, but R does not explain why reciprocity enforces symmetry—R only restates the property of symmetry.
Step-by-Step Solution:
State reciprocity condition: transfer functions are transposable → S_ij = S_ji for all i ≠ j.Conclude symmetry of S from reciprocity.Recognize R is a definition, not a causal explanation for A.Verification / Alternative check:Microwave textbooks prove symmetry using Lorentz reciprocity theorem applied to fields and ports. The diagonal terms are not constrained by reciprocity, but off-diagonals must match pairwise.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- A: True; B captures that R does not provide the causal link.
- C/D: Incorrectly deny the truth of either the assertion or the reason.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming nonreciprocal devices (circulators, isolators) also have symmetric S; they do not because reciprocity is violated.
Final Answer:Both A and R are correct but R is not correct explanation of A