Ramesh travels 760 km to his home, partly by train and partly by car. He takes 8 hours, if he travels 160 km by train and the rest by car. He takes 12 minutes more, if he travels 240 km by train and the rest by car. What are the speeds of the car and the train respectively? (M.A.T., 2006)
Aptitude
Time and Distance
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A90 km/hr, 60 km/hr
-
B100 km/hr, 80 km/hr
-
C80 km/hr, 70 km/hr
-
D100 km/hr, 90 km/hr
Answer
Correct Answer: 100 km/hr, 80 km/hr
Explanation
### Concept & Simultaneous Equations for Time and Distance
When total travel time is composed of two segments with different vehicles, we construct simultaneous linear equations using reciprocals of the unknown speeds.
Total Time $= \frac{Distance_{Train}}{Speed_{Train}} + \frac{Distance_{Car}}{Speed_{Car}}$
### Step-by-Step Solution
1. Let the speed of the train be $t$ km/hr and the speed of the car be $c$ km/hr.
2. Total distance is $760$ km.
3. **Case 1:** $160$ km by train and the rest ($760 - 160 = 600$ km) by car takes $8$ hours.
$$\frac{160}{t} + \frac{600}{c} = 8 \quad \text{--- (Equation 1)}$$
Divide by 8 for simplicity: $\frac{20}{t} + \frac{75}{c} = 1$
4. **Case 2:** $240$ km by train and the rest ($760 - 240 = 520$ km) by car takes $12$ minutes more ($8$ hours $12$ minutes).
Convert $12$ minutes to hours: $\frac{12}{60} = \frac{1}{5} = 0.2$ hours. Total time $= 8.2 = \frac{41}{5}$ hours.
$$\frac{240}{t} + \frac{520}{c} = \frac{41}{5} \quad \text{--- (Equation 2)}$$
Multiply by 5: $\frac{1200}{t} + \frac{2600}{c} = 41$
5. To solve, substitute $x = \frac{1}{t}$ and $y = \frac{1}{c}$:
$20x + 75y = 1 \quad \Rightarrow \text{Multiply by } 60: 1200x + 4500y = 60$
$1200x + 2600y = 41$
6. Subtract the second modified equation from the first:
$(1200x + 4500y) - (1200x + 2600y) = 60 - 41$
$1900y = 19$
$y = \frac{19}{1900} = \frac{1}{100}$
7. Since $y = \frac{1}{c}$, the speed of the car $c = 100$ km/hr.
8. Substitute $y$ back to find $x$:
$20x + 75\left(\frac{1}{100}\right) = 1$
$20x + \frac{3}{4} = 1$
$20x = \frac{1}{4}$
$x = \frac{1}{80}$
9. Since $x = \frac{1}{t}$, the speed of the train $t = 80$ km/hr.
10. The question asks for the speeds of the **car** and the **train** respectively.
Car speed $= 100$ km/hr, Train speed $= 80$ km/hr.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Notice the relative changes. Shifting $80$ km of distance from the car to the train ($160$ to $240$) increases the time by $12$ minutes ($\frac{1}{5}$ hour).
This implies the train is slower.
Use option checking: We need car speed and train speed respectively. Check option (b): $100$ km/hr (car), $80$ km/hr (train).
Case 1: $\frac{160}{80} + \frac{600}{100} = 2 + 6 = 8$ hours. Fits perfectly! No need to check Case 2 or do algebra.
### Common Pitfall
A very common trap is solving for $t = 80$ and $c = 100$, and then hastily picking an option that says "$80, 100$". You must read the final question carefully: it asks for the speeds of the **car** and the **train** *respectively*. The order matters!
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **100 km/hr, 80 km/hr**.