A owes B, ₹ 1573 payable $1\frac{1}{2}$ years hence. Also B owes A, ₹ 1444.50 payable 6 months hence. If they want to settle the account forthwith, keeping 14% as the rate of interest, then who should pay and how much? (a) A, ₹ 28.50 (b) B, ₹ 37.50 (c) A, ₹ 50 (d) B, ₹ 50
Aptitude
True Discount
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
A(a) A, ₹ 28.50
-
B(b) B, ₹ 37.50
-
C(c) A, ₹ 50
-
D(d) B, ₹ 50
Answer
Correct Answer: (d) B, ₹ 50
Explanation
### Concept & Present Worth Settle
To settle future debts "forthwith" (immediately), we must calculate the Present Worth (PW) of both debts today and find the net difference.
$$ \text{PW} = \frac{100 \times \text{Amount}}{100 + (R \times T)} $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
- **A's debt to B:**
Amount = ₹ 1573, Time = $1\frac{1}{2} = 1.5$ years, Rate = 14%.
$$ \text{PW}_A = \frac{1573 \times 100}{100 + (14 \times 1.5)} = \frac{157300}{100 + 21} = \frac{157300}{121} = 1300 $$
A presently owes B ₹ 1300.
- **B's debt to A:**
Amount = ₹ 1444.50, Time = 6 months = 0.5 years, Rate = 14%.
$$ \text{PW}_B = \frac{1444.50 \times 100}{100 + (14 \times 0.5)} = \frac{144450}{100 + 7} = \frac{144450}{107} = 1350 $$
B presently owes A ₹ 1350.
- **Net Settlement:**
Since B owes A ₹ 1350 and A owes B ₹ 1300, the net amount is $1350 - 1300 = 50$.
B must pay A ₹ 50 to settle the account.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Always bring all obligations to $t=0$ (Present Worth). The calculations are designed to be clean multiples. $1573$ is a known multiple of $121$ ($13 \times 121 = 1573$), and $144450 / 107$ ends in $50$. Quickly identifying these multiples saves calculation time.
### Common Pitfall
Calculating the interest on the final amounts rather than finding the present worth, or netting the future amounts directly without discounting them to the present day.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **(d) B, ₹ 50**.