A can build a wall in the same time in which B and C together can do it. If A and B together could do it in 25 days and C alone in 35 days, in what time could B alone do it?
Aptitude
Time and Work
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A90 days
-
B100 days
-
C175 days
-
DNone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: 175 days
Explanation
### Concept & Logic
If A takes the same time as B and C together, it means A's efficiency is equal to the combined efficiency of B and C. We can use this substitution to find individual work rates.
$$ A = B + C $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
1. **Establish the efficiency equations:**
Let A, B, and C represent their respective 1-day work rates.
Given: A = B + C
Given: A + B = $\frac{1}{25}$
Given: C = $\frac{1}{35}$
2. **Find the combined rate of A, B, and C:**
(A + B + C) = (A + B) + C
$(A + B + C) = \frac{1}{25} + \frac{1}{35}$
LCM of 25 and 35 is 175.
$(A + B + C) = \frac{7}{175} + \frac{5}{175} = \frac{12}{175}$
3. **Substitute A into the combined equation:**
Since A = B + C, we can replace (B + C) with A in the total rate.
$A + A = \frac{12}{175}$
$2A = \frac{12}{175} \implies A = \frac{6}{175}$
4. **Calculate B's 1-day work:**
We know A + B = $\frac{1}{25}$, which is equivalent to $\frac{7}{175}$.
Substitute A's value:
$\frac{6}{175} + B = \frac{7}{175}$
$B = \frac{7}{175} - \frac{6}{175} = \frac{1}{175}$
Since B's 1-day work is $\frac{1}{175}$, B alone will take 175 days.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Using efficiencies in terms of total units: Let Total Work = LCM(25, 35) = 175 units.
$(A+B)$ efficiency = 7 units/day.
C efficiency = 5 units/day.
Total $(A+B+C)$ efficiency = 12 units/day.
Since $A = B+C$, $A$ does half the total work and $(B+C)$ does the other half.
Efficiency of A = 6 units/day.
Since $(A+B) = 7$ and $A = 6$, $B = 1$ unit/day.
Time for B = $\frac{175}{1} = 175$ days.
### Common Pitfall
A common mistake is directly subtracting C's rate from $(A+B)$'s rate. This does not yield B's rate because A and B are grouped. You must use the equivalence relationship ($A = B+C$) to disentangle them.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **175 days**.