Identify the relation that is not an equation of state for real gases:
-
APV = RT + B/V + C/V^2 + … (virial form)
-
B(P + a/V^2)(V − b) = RT (van der Waals)
-
CAntoine equation for vapor pressure: log10 p^sat = A − B/(C + T)
-
DRedlich–Kwong equation of state
Answer
Correct Answer: Antoine equation for vapor pressure: log10 p^sat = A − B/(C + T)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Equations of state (EoS) relate P, V, and T of a fluid, enabling prediction of densities, fugacities, and phase behavior. Distinguishing EoS from empirical vapor-pressure correlations is critical when choosing models for design and simulation.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Real-gas behavior; need P–V–T relations for the bulk phase.
- Well-known EoS include virial, van der Waals, Redlich–Kwong, Peng–Robinson, etc.
- Antoine correlation gives p^sat(T) for a pure component; it is not a P–V–T relation.
Concept / Approach:An equation of state must connect pressure, temperature, and molar (or specific) volume. The virial equation expands compressibility in powers of 1/V (or in Z). Van der Waals and Redlich–Kwong are cubic EoS directly providing P as a function of T and V. The Antoine equation, however, correlates saturation pressure with temperature only for a pure component and does not provide V; it is a property correlation, not an EoS.
Step-by-Step Solution:List options: (a) virial → EoS; (b) van der Waals → EoS; (d) Redlich–Kwong → EoS; (c) Antoine → vapor-pressure correlation.Identify the odd one out: Antoine equation is not an equation of state.
Verification / Alternative check:Software workflows use Antoine for bubble/dew calculations together with an EoS or activity model; this division of roles underscores that Antoine is not an EoS.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:They are true equations of state connecting P–V–T for gases/fluids.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing property correlations (Antoine) with EoS; assuming any pressure–temperature formula is an EoS.
Final Answer:Antoine equation for vapor pressure: log10 p^sat = A − B/(C + T)