Isotopes and radioactivity: which of the following hydrogen isotopes is intrinsically radioactive by nature?
-
AHelium
-
BDeuterium
-
CHeavy hydrogen (same as deuterium)
-
DTritium
-
EProtium
Answer
Correct Answer: Tritium
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Hydrogen has three isotopes of interest: protium (H-1), deuterium (H-2), and tritium (H-3). Recognizing which isotope is radioactive is important in fusion research, radiolabeling, and environmental monitoring.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- We compare stability of hydrogen isotopes.
- Terminology: “heavy hydrogen” is deuterium.
- Helium is included as a distractor and is a different element entirely.
Concept / Approach:Protium (H-1) and deuterium (H-2) are stable. Tritium (H-3) is radioactive, undergoing beta decay to helium-3 with a half-life of about 12.3 years. Therefore, among the options, only tritium is intrinsically radioactive.
Step-by-Step Solution:List isotopes: H-1 (stable), H-2 = deuterium/heavy hydrogen (stable), H-3 = tritium (radioactive).Identify the radioactive one: tritium.Eliminate helium and duplicate naming of deuterium (“heavy hydrogen”).
Verification / Alternative check:Standard nuclear data handbooks confirm tritium's beta decay to He-3, widely used in fusion research and self-luminous devices (with strict safety controls).
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Helium: Different element; stable isotopes He-3 and He-4.
- Deuterium/heavy hydrogen: Stable.
- Protium: Stable.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing “heavy hydrogen” with tritium; heavy hydrogen is deuterium, which is stable.
Final Answer:Tritium