Entropy concepts — choose the correct statement: Which of the following best aligns with the thermodynamic meaning of entropy and its relation to heat–to–work conversion?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: The change in entropy may be regarded as a measure of the unavailability of heat for transformation into work.

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Entropy connects heat transfer with temperature and sets fundamental limits on converting heat into work. Identifying a correct qualitative statement about entropy strengthens intuition for the Second Law and availability (exergy) concepts used in real plant analysis.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Reversible reference for entropy change: dS = dQ_rev / T.
  • Temperature measured on the Kelvin scale.
  • Availability (exergy) represents the useful work potential relative to an environment.


Concept / Approach:
Entropy growth quantifies degradation of energy quality. For a given heat quantity, adding it at low temperature increases entropy more (dS = dQ/T), which reduces the portion potentially convertible to work. Thus, entropy change is tightly linked to the unavailability of energy for work, not to the “maximum obtainable work per degree” (that belongs to exergy analysis and Carnot factors).


Step-by-Step Solution:
Interpret option B: it states entropy change gauges unavailability of heat for work. This aligns with Second-Law reasoning and exergy loss being T0 * ΔS_gen.Consider option A: while it is true that dS is larger at lower T for a given dQ, it is incomplete as the “best” statement of entropy’s role in availability.Evaluate option C: claims entropy directly equals maximum work per degree drop—this is incorrect; maximum work relates to temperature levels via Carnot efficiency and exergy, not entropy alone.Hence, the most appropriate and correct statement is B.


Verification / Alternative check:
Exergy destruction equals T0 * S_gen. Larger entropy generation directly implies greater lost work, reinforcing option B’s framing.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A is true but narrower and less definitive about entropy’s meaning; C is incorrect in definition; D cannot be right because C is wrong.


Common Pitfalls:
Equating entropy with “disorder” only; ignoring that engineering relevance is in work potential relative to an environment at T0.


Final Answer:
The change in entropy may be regarded as a measure of the unavailability of heat for transformation into work.

More Questions from Thermodynamics

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion