In evolutionary biology, which of the following clades does NOT include humans as members?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Diapsids, the clade that includes most reptiles and birds

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This question comes from evolutionary biology and phylogeny. It asks you to identify which clade does not contain humans. Clades are groups of organisms that include a common ancestor and all its descendants. Understanding which clades humans belong to helps you see how our species fits into the broader tree of life and clarifies relationships with other vertebrates such as fish, reptiles, and mammals.


Given Data / Assumptions:


    • The clades listed are diapsids, craniates, synapsids, and lobe fins.
    • Humans are vertebrates and mammals with specific skeletal features.
    • The question asks where humans are excluded, based on evolutionary relationships.


Concept / Approach:
Craniates are chordates that have a skull; this clade includes fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals, so humans definitely belong here. Lobe fins (Sarcopterygii) are the clade of lobe finned fishes and their descendants. Tetrapods, including amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals, evolved from lobe finned ancestors, so humans are nested within lobe fins. Synapsids are amniotes with a single temporal opening in the skull behind each eye; this clade includes mammals and their extinct “mammal like reptile” ancestors, so humans, as mammals, are synapsids. Diapsids are amniotes with two temporal openings on each side of the skull and include most reptiles and birds, such as lizards, snakes, crocodiles, and modern birds. Mammals, including humans, are not diapsids; they belong to synapsids instead.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Step 1: Confirm that humans are mammals, and mammals are part of the synapsid clade due to their characteristic skull openings. Step 2: Recognise that mammals evolved from lobe finned fish ancestors, placing humans within the broader lobe fins clade. Step 3: Recall that craniates include all vertebrates with skulls, including humans, so humans are clearly craniates. Step 4: Understand that diapsids include most reptiles and birds, but not mammals; mammals belong to a different branch (synapsids). Step 5: Therefore, the one clade listed that excludes humans is the diapsids clade.


Verification / Alternative check:
Phylogenetic trees in biology textbooks show vertebrate evolution starting from lobe finned fishes and branching into amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals. These diagrams label mammals under synapsids and show reptiles and birds under diapsids. They also place all these vertebrates in the larger craniate group because they all have skulls. The only branch that does not include mammals or humans is the diapsid branch, which contains reptiles and birds. This supports the conclusion that diapsids do not include humans, while the other clades do.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Craniates, animals that possess a skull, is wrong because humans clearly have skulls and are therefore craniates.

Synapsids, the clade that includes mammals and their extinct relatives, is incorrect as an answer because humans are mammals and so are synapsids.

Lobe fins, the clade of lobe finned fishes and their terrestrial descendants, is also wrong because tetrapods, including humans, evolved from lobe finned ancestors and are part of this broader clade.


Common Pitfalls:
Students often assume that humans belong only to the mammal group and forget that mammals are embedded within several larger clades. Another pitfall is to confuse synapsids and diapsids because both names refer to skull openings. To avoid this, remember the key association: diapsids are mainly reptiles and birds, synapsids are mammals and their ancestors. Since humans are mammals, we fall under synapsids, not diapsids, making diapsids the correct choice for the clade that does not include humans.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion