In basic chemistry, which of the following cannot be regarded as a single phase in a physical system?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: A heterogeneous mixture

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
In chemistry and thermodynamics, the concept of a phase is used to describe regions of matter that are uniform in composition and physical properties. Understanding phases is important when analysing mixtures, solutions, and changes of state. Questions about phases are common in school level chemistry and engineering entrance exams. This question asks which type of material cannot be considered a single phase, so you need to distinguish between homogeneous and heterogeneous systems and recall what makes a phase uniform.


Given Data / Assumptions:
- The options include heterogeneous mixtures, pure solids, pure liquids, and homogeneous mixtures.
- A phase is defined by uniform physical and chemical properties in the region considered.
- Pure substances and homogeneous mixtures are typically single phase within the region examined.
- Heterogeneous mixtures contain visibly distinct or compositionally different parts.


Concept / Approach:
A phase is a portion of a system that is uniform in composition and properties. A pure solid or a pure liquid, such as pure ice or pure water, is uniform throughout and therefore represents a single phase. A homogeneous mixture, such as a solution of salt in water that is completely uniform, is also considered a single phase. In contrast, a heterogeneous mixture, such as sand in water or oil and water, contains more than one region with different composition or physical properties. Each distinct region is a separate phase. Therefore, the entire heterogeneous mixture cannot be called a single phase because it consists of multiple phases together.


Step-by-Step Solution:
1. Recall that a phase is a part of a system that is uniform in composition and physical state. 2. Consider a pure solid: all parts are the same substance in the same state, so it is a single phase. 3. Consider a pure liquid: again, all parts are identical in composition and state, so it is a single phase. 4. Consider a homogeneous mixture: although it contains more than one substance, they are uniformly distributed, so the mixture is one uniform phase. 5. Consider a heterogeneous mixture: it has regions with different composition or states, so it actually contains more than one phase and cannot be regarded as a single phase.


Verification / Alternative check:
If you draw diagrams of common examples, the difference becomes clear. A beaker of salt solution appears completely uniform and has one liquid phase. A block of pure copper metal is uniform and represents one solid phase. However, a mixture of oil and water clearly separates into an upper oil layer and a lower water layer. These two layers are two different liquid phases within the same container, making the overall mixture heterogeneous. In some heterogeneous mixtures, there may also be solid and liquid phases together, such as muddy water. Each distinct region is its own phase, so the whole mixture cannot be described as a single phase.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A pure solid: Because it is uniform in composition and state, it is a single phase.
A pure liquid: This is also uniform and therefore a single phase.
A homogeneous mixture: Even though it contains more than one chemical species, they are uniformly mixed and behave as a single phase in the region considered.


Common Pitfalls:
Some learners may think that the word mixture automatically means multiple phases, but mixtures can be either homogeneous or heterogeneous. A solution is a mixture but still a single phase. Another mistake is to assume that only pure substances can be phases, which is not true because a homogeneous solution is also a phase. The key is to focus on uniformity of properties, not on purity of substance. Recognising this helps avoid confusion between homogeneous and heterogeneous systems.


Final Answer:
A heterogeneous mixture cannot be regarded as a single phase because it contains more than one distinct phase within it.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion