Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: An error first callback is a function where the first argument represents an error object or null, and the subsequent arguments carry successful result data.
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Node.js popularised a specific pattern for asynchronous callbacks known as the error first callback style. Understanding this pattern is important for reading existing Node.js code and for writing functions that behave consistently with the ecosystem. This question asks you to define what an error first callback is and describe the order of its parameters.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
In the error first callback convention, an asynchronous function accepts a callback with a signature that places the error parameter first. When the operation completes, the function calls the callback. If an error occurred, the first parameter is set to an error object and result parameters may be omitted or set to undefined. If the operation succeeded, the first parameter is null and the subsequent parameters contain the result data. This uniform pattern makes it easy to detect errors using simple checks in the callback and was widely used before the adoption of promises and async or await syntax.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recall that in Node.js, callbacks commonly have the form function(err, result) or function(err, data1, data2).Step 2: Recognise that err is null on success and contains an error object when there is a failure.Step 3: Option A states that an error first callback takes an error object or null as the first argument and result data in later arguments.Step 4: Option B incorrectly suggests that error first callbacks must throw exceptions.Step 5: Option C and option D misrepresent the role and ordering of arguments, so option A is the correct explanation.
Verification / Alternative check:
Common Node.js APIs such as fs.readFile(path, callback) call the callback with function(err, data). When a file is read successfully, err is null and data contains the file contents. When an error occurs, err contains details and data is typically undefined or not used. Documentation explicitly describes this as the error first callback pattern, matching the description in option A.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option B confuses callback based error signalling with exceptions; in Node.js, callbacks are used because they work across asynchronous boundaries where traditional try or catch around the original call would not see the error. Option C claims that the callback never receives error information, which is the opposite of the pattern. Option D moves the error parameter to the end, which breaks the standard convention and would make error handling less consistent.
Common Pitfalls:
New developers sometimes forget to follow the error first convention when writing their own APIs, leading to inconsistent code that is harder to use. Another pitfall is ignoring the err parameter in callbacks, which can hide failures and complicate debugging. As Node.js codebases move toward promises and async or await, understanding error first callbacks is still essential for maintaining legacy code and for interoperating with older modules.
Final Answer:
An error first callback is a function where the first argument represents an error object or null, and the subsequent arguments carry successful result data.
Discussion & Comments