Statement Should sale of vital human organs be made legal in India? Argument I. No, it goes against our culture. II. No, this will lead to unhealthy practices. III. Yes, this will bring an end to the illegal trading of human organs.

Question

Accepted Answer

Argument I is weak because talking of culture is irrelevant in this case. Infact, Argument I is not even true. Argument II is weak because it is simplistic. We are not told what these unhealthy practices' will be. Argument III is weak because it is superfluous.

Statement Should sale of vital human organs be made legal in India? Argument I. No, it goes against our culture. II. No, this will lead to unhealthy practices. III. Yes, this will bring an end to the illegal trading of human organs.

Discussion & Comments