Statement: Should sale and purchase of human organs be made legal in India? Arguments: I. Yes, in many countries sale and purchase of human organs is not considered illegal. II. No, this will open the floodgates for the sale of human organs.

Question

Accepted Answer

I is not strong because we can not make anything legal merely on the basis of the approach of foreign countries toward it. Because there are various factors which affect it and these factors vary from one country to another. Argument II is weak because it does not add anything substantial to the statement.

Statement: Should sale and purchase of human organs be made legal in India? Arguments: I. Yes, in many countries sale and purchase of human organs is not considered illegal. II. No, this will open the floodgates for the sale of human organs.

Discussion & Comments