Home » Verbal Reasoning » Statement and Argument

Statement: Should sale and purchase of human organs be made legal in India? Arguments: I. Yes, in many countries sale and purchase of human organs is not considered illegal. II. No, this will open the floodgates for the sale of human organs.

if only argument I is strong
if only argument II is strong
if either I or II is strong
if neither I nor II is strong

Correct Answer: if neither I nor II is strong

Explanation:

I is not strong because we can not make anything legal merely on the basis of the approach of foreign countries toward it. Because there are various factors which affect it and these factors vary from one country to another. Argument II is weak because it does not add anything substantial to the statement.

← Previous Question Next Question→

More Questions from Statement and Argument

Statement Should India immediately stop digging coal from its mines? Arguments I. Yes the present stock of coal will not last long if we continue mining at the present rate. II. No, we do not have alternate energy resources in sufficient quantity. III. No this will put millions of people at a disadvantage and their lives will get adversely and also the industry.
Statement Should there be a total ban on tobacco products and smoking in India? Arguments I. Yes, it is wrong to smoke away millions of rupees. II. No, thousands of workers in the tobacco industry will be not out of employment. III. No, the Government will lose huge amount of money which it earns by way of taxes on these products.
Statement Should mercy death be legalised,i.e.,all those who are suffering from terminal diseases be allowed to end their lives if desires so ? Arguments I. No, nobody should be allowed to end his/her life as this goes against the basic tenets of humanity. II. Yes patients undergoing terrible suffering and having absolutely no chance of recovery Should be liberated from them suffering through mercy death. III. No even mercy death is a killing and killing can never be legalised.
Statement Should women be given equal opportunities in the matter of employment in every field? Arguments I. Yes they are equally capable II. No, they have to shoulder household responsibilities III. Yes, they Should also go into the outside world.
Which of the following, If true, most strengthens the above argument?
Which of the following, If true , most weakens the above argument?
Nations do not compete with each other in the way corporations do. Which of the following, If true, most weakens the above argument?
Not only do major diseases afflict the elderly in particular of which there are more they are generally very expensive diseases to meet . Which of the following options, if true, most strengthens this statements?
Statement Should sale of vital human organs be made legal in India? Argument I. No, it goes against our culture. II. No, this will lead to unhealthy practices. III. Yes, this will bring an end to the illegal trading of human organs.
Statement Should the conscription of citizens for defence service be made compulsory in India? Argument I. Yes, this is the only way to tackle the serious shortage of manpower in defence services. II. No, instead the compensation package be made comparable to other job sectors to attract people to join defence services. III. Yes, many other countries have made this compulsory.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Join Discussion