Statement: Should the provision to dissolve the assembly prematurely be amended? Arguments: I. Yes. On many occasions the provision has been used by ruling Governments to fulfil their vested interests. II. No. To fulfil the constitutional obligations and norms, it sometimes becomes the need of the hour to dissolve the assembly prematurely.

if only argument I is strong.
if only argument II is strong.
If either I or II is strong.
if neither I nor II is strong

Correct Answer: if neither I nor II is strong

Explanation:

I is weak because it merely talks of the provision being abused. It does not point to any weakness inherent in the provision. II is weak because it seems to equate ''amendment'' with ''abolition''.

← Previous Question Next Question→

More Questions from Statement and Argument

Statement: Should AIDS test be made mandatory in India for brides and grooms before marriage? Arguments: I. Yes. India is one of the countries where the number of AIDS victims is the highest. It is essential for India to make efforts to restrict the number of victims. II. No. It will be a humiliation of brides and grooms both.
Statement: Should there be a censor board for supervising advertisements issued by different companies? Arguments: I. No, It is impractical to have sensor boards for various purposes. II. Yes, On many occasion it has been witnessed that an advertisement has created a lot of debate by showing such scenes in the advertisement as are detrimental to our social fabric.
Statement: Should students be allowed to work while they are studying? Arguments: I. Yes. Economic background of every individual does not allow them to pursue education; such allowing therefore makes it feasible to fulfil one 's dream. II. Yes. Vocational education plays an important role to make a person self-sufficient. Besides, this practical knowledge becomes necessary to make studies meaningful.
Statement: Should the employer have the right to terminate the service of an employee on the ground of disability? Arguments: I. Yes. The employee plays an important role in achieving the employer 's objective. If an employee become unable to perform the role because of disability, the employer must have the right to terminate the service of the employee. II. No. Humanity can't be ignored. If our constitution facilitates reservation in jobs for the disabled, why think of termination of service if a normal person becomes disabled?
Statement: Should the person debarred from contesting election by the Election Commission be allowed to become the Chief minister of state? Arguments: I. No, because if a debarred person is allowed to hold the office of chief minister, he/she will not be able to become an MLA or MLC within the stipulated period of six months according to the Indian Constitution. II. Yes, we are a democracy ruled by people and not by law alone. Therefore judicial conviction should be set aside by people 's mandate.
Statement: Should the government enact stricter laws against the spread of hutment colonies? Arguments: I. No, it is incumbent upon the government to provide food, shelter and clothing for every citizen. II. Yes, huntsmen colonies are spreading rapidly and in future it may affect population -civic amenities equilibrium.
Statement: Should scientists be allowed to go for human cloning? Arguments: I. Yes, human cloning is going to be a terrific way to beat diseases and will give childless couples an opportunity to have baby. II. No, experts say that serious malformations have occurred in all species cloned so far, and it is sure it will happen in humans too. Scientists should not be allowed to meddle with nature.
Statement: Should various State Electricity Boards conduct raids check use of ACs during peak hours? Arguments : I. Yes, electricity is one of the main sources of energy which facilitates people many amenities, therefore it is necessary to save electricity during peak hours. II. No, in fact, what should really be checked is whether the person is actually exceeding the installed or the connected load than is justified and it is a common sight to see many connections running illegally form a pole to pilfer electricity.
Statement: Should a person found guilty in a rape case be given capital punishment? Arguments: I. Yes, such a harsh punishment will be able to reduce grievous crimes against women. This punishment will compel atrocious persons having similar bent of mind to change their behavior. II. No, any such step will endanger the life of the victim because the culprit might kill the victim to wipe out all the evidence .
Statement: Should government doctors be brought within the purview of the Consumer Protection Act? Arguments: I. No, any such will endanger the life of the patient because it will impose some hindrances to the doctors in some cases in which patients are in critical condition. II. Yes, a patient invests money in improving his/her health. He/she has full right to get required service form doctors and if he/she incurs any loss then for compensation it is necessary to bring the doctors within the purview of the Consumer Protection Act.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Join Discussion