Analyze statements
- : C is A's brother and son of E ⇒ E is a parent of C (and likely A), but E's relation to D is unknown; cannot identify A's father.
- : F is mother of B. Since B is a child of D and already has mother F, D must be the father of B. Therefore D is male (father). A is also a child of D ⇒ A's father is D.
Conclusion
Statement (2) alone suffices; (1) alone does not.
Discussion & Comments