Unit check: since Young’s modulus E is defined as stress divided by strain (and strain is dimensionless), is the unit of E the same as the unit of stress?

Mechanical Engineering Strength of Materials Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    True
  • B
    False
  • C
    True only in SI units
  • D
    True only for metals
  • E
    False unless ν = 0

Answer

Correct Answer: True

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Dimensional consistency is crucial in mechanics. Young’s modulus quantifies stiffness as the ratio of stress to strain and therefore inherits the units of stress.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • E = stress / strain.
  • Strain is dimensionless (change in length / original length).
  • Any coherent unit system (SI, CGS, U.S. customary) is acceptable.

Concept / Approach:Because strain has no dimensions, the dimensions of E are exactly those of stress. In SI units, stress is in pascals (Pa = N/m^2), so E is also in pascals. In practice, engineers use MPa or GPa for convenience.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Define E = sigma / epsilon.epsilon has no units.Therefore, [E] = [sigma] = force / area.

Verification / Alternative check:Check typical values: steels have E ≈ 200 GPa, which is a stress unit magnitude, confirming the reasoning.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:“False”: contradicts the definition.Conditions like “only in SI” or “only for metals” are irrelevant; the dimensional reasoning is universal.

Common Pitfalls:Confusing modulus units with material-dependent numbers; the unit type is always the same as stress, regardless of the material.

Final Answer:

True

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion