Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: The Lok Sabha
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
The Union Budget is a key annual event in the functioning of the Government of India. It outlines the estimated revenue and expenditure for the coming financial year and reflects the economic priorities of the government. This question tests your knowledge of parliamentary procedure, specifically where the Budget is first presented. For exam preparation, it is essential to know how financial control is exercised and which House has the primary role in money matters.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
Under the Constitution, money bills and financial proposals are primarily the domain of the Lok Sabha. The Rajya Sabha has limited powers regarding money bills; it can discuss and make recommendations, but the Lok Sabha is not bound to accept them. The Union Budget is introduced as the general budget and related appropriation and finance bills in the Lok Sabha first. Only after the Lok Sabha has considered them do they go to the Rajya Sabha. Cabinet meetings are internal executive meetings and are not part of the formal presentation to the legislature.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recognise that the Union Budget is a financial proposal and is treated as part of the money bill process.
Step 2: Recall that Article 109 and related provisions state that money bills can only be introduced in the Lok Sabha.
Step 3: Understand that the Budget speech of the Finance Minister is delivered in the Lok Sabha, where the Budget is formally laid on the table.
Step 4: After introduction in the Lok Sabha, the Budget is later transmitted to the Rajya Sabha for discussion.
Step 5: Therefore, the Union Budget is always presented first in the Lok Sabha.
Verification / Alternative check:
To cross check, think about the powers of the Rajya Sabha in financial matters. The Rajya Sabha cannot initiate a money bill, and it can only suggest changes within a limited time. This confirms that the formal presentation of the Union Budget must occur in the Lok Sabha. Joint sessions are used mainly to resolve deadlocks on ordinary bills, not for initial presentation of the Budget. Cabinet meetings occur before presentation, but they are internal executive decisions, not the budget presentation to the nation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
The Rajya Sabha: It can discuss the Budget and make recommendations but does not receive the initial presentation of the Union Budget or introduce money bills.
Joint session of the Parliament: Joint sessions are rare and used to resolve deadlocks between the two Houses for certain ordinary bills, not for presenting the Budget.
Meeting of the Union Cabinet: The Cabinet approves the Budget proposals before presentation, but this is an internal executive process and not the formal parliamentary presentation asked in the question.
Common Pitfalls:
Some learners confuse the role of both Houses and assume that important national documents must be presented in a joint session. In reality, the Constitution gives special financial powers to the Lok Sabha as the directly elected House representing the people. Another pitfall is to think of the Budget only as an economic document and forget its constitutional status as a bundle of financial bills which follow strict procedural rules. Remember the simple rule: money bills and the Budget originate only in the Lok Sabha.
Final Answer:
The Union Budget is always presented first in the Lok Sabha.
Discussion & Comments