Igneous Petrology — What Controls the Rock Type That Forms from Magma? In igneous geology, the specific type of igneous rock that crystallises from a magma depends on multiple factors. Which factors collectively govern the rock that ultimately forms?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: All of the above

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Igneous rocks form when molten material (magma or lava) cools and solidifies. Petrologists classify these rocks based on mineral content, texture, and genesis. The final rock type is not determined by a single variable; instead, multiple controls act together during crystallisation to produce the observed mineral assemblages and textures.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Magma has a definable bulk chemistry (silica, alkalis, iron, magnesium, calcium, etc.).
  • Cooling occurs over a temperature range and may be slow (plutonic) or fast (volcanic).
  • Textures (grain size, porphyritic character, glassiness) reflect cooling history and nucleation/growth kinetics.


Concept / Approach:

Mineralogy follows compositional rules (e.g., basaltic vs granitic chemistries) and phase equilibria. Temperature determines which minerals are stable at a given moment, while the rate of cooling controls crystal size and the extent to which equilibrium is achieved. The interaction among composition, temperature, and cooling rate produces the spectrum of igneous rocks from fine-grained basalts to coarse-grained granites, including porphyritic and glassy varieties.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Composition sets potential minerals: silica-rich magmas tend to quartz, K-feldspar, muscovite; silica-poor to olivine, pyroxene, Ca-plagioclase.Temperature path dictates crystallisation sequence and stability fields for minerals as the melt cools.Cooling rate governs texture: slow cooling → coarse grains; rapid cooling → fine grains or glass; mixed cooling → porphyritic textures.Combine factors: the same chemistry can yield different textures under different cooling histories, and different chemistries yield different mineral suites at similar temperatures.


Verification / Alternative check:

Phase diagrams and experimental petrology demonstrate mineral appearance/disappearance with changing temperature and composition; natural examples (e.g., shallow dikes vs deep plutons) show texture shifts due to cooling rate.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Single-factor choices ignore the coupled influence of chemistry, temperature path, and kinetics, leading to incomplete predictions.


Common Pitfalls:

Assuming texture alone defines rock type; both mineralogy (from composition) and texture (from cooling rate) must be considered, along with the temperature history.


Final Answer:

All of the above

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion