2’s-complement arithmetic: Before adding or subtracting signed binary numbers, operands of different original widths must be sign-extended so that the operation occurs at the same bit width. Evaluate the claim that it is not necessary to have the same number of bits.

Digital Electronics Digital Arithmetic Operations and Circuits Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    Correct
  • B
    Incorrect
  • C
    Ambiguous as stated
  • D
    Cannot be determined without additional data

Answer

Correct Answer: Incorrect

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Signed arithmetic in digital systems is typically implemented with 2's complement representation. Correct results require consistent bit width so that sign bits align and carries/borrows propagate properly.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Operands may originate with different declared widths (e.g., 5-bit and 8-bit).
  • 2's complement addition/subtraction rules apply.
  • Overflow detection depends on consistent sign-bit alignment.

Concept / Approach:When widths differ, you must sign-extend the smaller operand to the larger width, duplicating its sign bit into higher positions. Arithmetic is then performed at a single, common width. Saying “not necessary to have the same number of bits” is misleading; operations take place at one width after proper extension.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify operand widths n and m (assume n < m).Sign-extend the n-bit operand to m bits by repeating its MSB.Perform addition/subtraction at m bits.Evaluate overflow using sign-bit rules at width m.

Verification / Alternative check:HDL synthesis and ISA specifications (e.g., sign-extension on load/extend instructions) formalize this requirement for correctness and overflow semantics.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Correct: Would imply mismatched widths can be directly added without extension.
  • Ambiguous / Cannot be determined: The rule is well-defined in 2's complement arithmetic.

Common Pitfalls:Zero-extending negative numbers (wrong) or ignoring width differences, causing sign errors and incorrect overflow flags.

Final Answer:Incorrect

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion