Active filter order vs roll-off: A two-pole (second-order) active filter exhibits a stopband roll-off of −20 dB/decade. Is this statement accurate?
-
ACorrect
-
BIncorrect
-
COnly true for unity-gain Sallen–Key
-
DOnly true at the exact cutoff frequency
-
ETrue for low-pass but not for high-pass
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Filter order determines asymptotic attenuation slope beyond the cutoff region. Each reactive pole contributes an additional −20 dB/decade (or −6 dB/octave) in the stopband. Understanding this principle is core to predicting selectivity and choosing between first- and second-order topologies in active RC designs such as Sallen–Key or multiple-feedback filters.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- “Two-pole” means a second-order low-pass, high-pass, band-pass, or band-stop realized actively.
- Asymptotic stopband behavior is considered (well beyond cutoff).
- Standard linear, time-invariant response without special equalization.
Concept / Approach:For a first-order (one-pole) filter, the far-stopband slope is −20 dB/decade. For a second-order (two-pole) filter, slopes add to −40 dB/decade. This is independent of whether the active form is Sallen–Key, multiple-feedback, or biquad. While passband ripple/peaking depends on Q or damping ratio, the asymptotic slope is set by order alone.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify order: two poles ⇒ second order.Each pole contributes −20 dB/decade in the stopband.Total asymptotic slope = −40 dB/decade.Therefore, the statement claiming −20 dB/decade is incorrect.Verification / Alternative check:Bode magnitude plots of standard 2nd-order Butterworth, Bessel, or Chebyshev sections all show a −40 dB/decade asymptote. Cascading two first-order stages demonstrates the same cumulative slope.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:“True for unity-gain Sallen–Key” is false; gain does not change the asymptotic order. “Only at cutoff” confuses the local slope near the corner with the far-stopband asymptote. High-pass and low-pass of the same order share the same magnitude slope magnitude in their respective stopbands.
Common Pitfalls:Equating peaking or damping with slope; mistaking the −3 dB point behavior for the asymptotic roll-off far from cutoff.
Final Answer:Incorrect