Thermistors — correct physical effect: “A thermistor is a semiconductor device that acts like a piezoresistive resistor.” Decide if this identification of the underlying effect is accurate.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Incorrect

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Thermistors and piezoresistive elements are both resistive sensors but respond to different stimuli. Mixing these concepts results in selecting the wrong sensor for temperature or force/pressure measurement tasks.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Thermistor: temperature-sensitive semiconductor resistor (NTC or PTC).
  • Piezoresistive element: resistance changes due to mechanical strain (as in strain gauges or MEMS bridges).
  • Small-signal measurement context with proper biasing to limit self-heating.


Concept / Approach:
A thermistor’s resistance varies primarily with temperature due to semiconductor carrier concentration changes; it does not rely on mechanical stress. Piezoresistive devices, by contrast, change resistance when stressed (pressure, acceleration, strain). Therefore, stating that a thermistor “acts like a piezoresistive resistor” is incorrect; the correct term is “thermoresistive” or “temperature-dependent resistor.”


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify sensing principle: thermistor → temperature dependence of resistance.Contrast with piezoresistivity: resistance change with mechanical strain.Note typical use: thermistors in temperature sensing/compensation networks.Conclude the statement is inaccurate.


Verification / Alternative check:
NTC thermistors exhibit a negative temperature coefficient; datasheets specify R–T curves and Beta values, not gauge factor. Piezoresistive sensors specify sensitivity to strain/pressure and gauge factors, confirming the different physics.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Correct: False; thermistors are temperature sensors, not strain sensors.
  • Valid only for NTC types: Both NTC and PTC respond to temperature, not stress.
  • True under mechanical stress: Any incidental stress sensitivity is a secondary effect, not the sensing principle.
  • Depends on self-heating: Self-heating alters apparent temperature but does not change the sensor’s fundamental effect.


Common Pitfalls:
Confusing “piezoresistive” with “thermoresistive”; overlooking self-heating errors and required bias limits in precision temperature measurements.


Final Answer:
Incorrect

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion