In Indian classical music theory there are ten basic "thaats" or parent scales that form the foundation for many ragas. These ten thaats belong to which of the following systems of music?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Hindustani music

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This question is about the theoretical framework of Indian classical music. It asks specifically about the concept of ten "thaats", which are parent scales from which many ragas are derived. Recognising whether thaats belong to the Hindustani or Carnatic system is an important aspect of cultural and performing arts general knowledge.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The term used is "thaat", which refers to a type of scale in Indian classical music.
  • The question mentions that there are ten such thaats or scales.
  • The options list different musical traditions, including Hindustani and Carnatic music.
  • Only one of these systems formally uses the ten thaat classification in its standard theory.


Concept / Approach:
In Indian classical music there are two major traditions: Hindustani music of North India and Carnatic music of South India. The concept of ten thaats as proposed by Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande is central to Hindustani music. Each thaat is a parent scale containing seven notes in a particular arrangement, and many ragas are grouped under these thaats. Carnatic music, on the other hand, uses the system of seventy two melakarta ragas as parent scales, not the ten thaats framework.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify that the term "thaat" is strongly associated with Hindustani classical music. Step 2: Recall that Bhatkhande classified Hindustani ragas under ten principal thaats, such as Bilawal, Kalyan and Bhairavi. Step 3: Remember that Carnatic music theory instead uses melakarta ragas and not the ten thaat system. Step 4: Eliminate Western classical, folk and Chinese traditional music, which have completely different theoretical bases. Step 5: Conclude that Hindustani music is the only correct answer among the given options.


Verification / Alternative check:
You can cross check this by recalling that music textbooks and general knowledge references often present a table of the ten Hindustani thaats and the ragas under them. They clearly attribute this system to North Indian classical music. For Carnatic music, standard books talk about melakarta and janya ragas instead. This clear difference between the two traditions confirms that the ten thaat system belongs to Hindustani music only.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Carnatic music is an Indian classical system but does not use the ten thaat scheme; it has its own melakarta raga system.
Western classical music uses concepts like major and minor scales, modes and harmonies, not the Indian thaat framework.
Folk music is a broad category with many regional styles, but it does not follow the formal ten thaat classification of Hindustani theory.
Chinese traditional music has its own pentatonic and other scale systems and is unrelated to the Indian thaat terminology.


Common Pitfalls:
A typical mistake is to see the term "Indian classical music" in the question and immediately mark Carnatic music without considering the specific theory mentioned. Another pitfall is to assume that both Hindustani and Carnatic use the same parent scale system, which is not correct. To avoid confusion, always remember that ten thaats correspond to Hindustani music and seventy two melakarta ragas correspond to Carnatic music. This mental pairing helps you answer similar questions quickly and accurately.


Final Answer:
The ten thaats or parent scales referred to in the question belong to the system of Hindustani music.

More Questions from Basic General Knowledge

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion