Compound Steam Engines — Flywheel Requirement for Tandem Arrangement Evaluate the statement: “A tandem-type compound steam engine requires a larger flywheel.” Consider how torque fluctuations differ from cross-compound arrangements.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: True

Explanation:


Introduction:
Compound engines split expansion across high-pressure (HP) and low-pressure (LP) cylinders to improve efficiency. The mechanical arrangement (tandem vs. cross-compound) affects turning-moment uniformity and thus the size of flywheel needed to smooth speed fluctuations through the cycle.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Tandem compound: HP and LP in line on the same piston rod acting on the same crank (cranks effectively 0° apart).
  • Cross-compound: Cylinders on separate cranks typically at 90°, yielding phase-shifted torque contributions.
  • Objective: reduce cyclic speed variation by energy storage in the flywheel.


Concept / Approach:
Flywheels mitigate fluctuations by storing/releasing kinetic energy as torque deviates from mean. When multiple cylinders deliver their peaks out of phase (e.g., 90°), the combined torque is more uniform, so a smaller flywheel suffices. In a tandem arrangement, both cylinders act in phase on the same crank, so torque peaks and troughs align, increasing fluctuation and requiring a larger flywheel to keep speed within limits.



Step-by-Step Solution:
Model torque T(θ) as sum of cylinder contributions.For tandem: T_total(θ) ≈ T_HP(θ) + T_LP(θ) with same phase ⇒ higher amplitude of fluctuation.For cross-compound: phase shift near 90° reduces resultant fluctuation factor.Flywheel energy coefficient depends on fluctuation of energy per cycle, which is larger for the tandem case ⇒ larger flywheel moment of inertia needed.


Verification / Alternative check:
Design texts show lower coefficient of fluctuation of speed for multi-cylinder engines with cranks evenly spaced, validating the argument for larger flywheels when torque sources are in phase.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • False: ignores phasing effects that increase fluctuation for tandem.
  • Speed-specific or single-acting qualifiers: the need arises from torque phasing, not merely speed or acting mode.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming “more cylinders” always means smoother torque; phasing and crank geometry matter as much as cylinder count.



Final Answer:
True

More Questions from Steam Boilers and Engines

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion