Switching vs. linear regulators — comparative statement: Switching voltage regulators have ______ than linear regulators. Choose the attribute that is generally superior in switching designs under comparable conditions.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: greater efficiency

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Power-conversion choices often reduce to linear regulators versus switching regulators. Designers balance efficiency, noise, cost, complexity, and thermal performance. This question asks which attribute switching regulators generally excel at relative to linear regulators when both meet the same output requirements.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Regulators compared at similar input/output voltages and power levels.
  • Standard industry topologies: buck, boost, buck-boost (switching) versus series pass (linear).
  • Thermal considerations and conduction/switching loss included conceptually.


Concept / Approach:
Switching regulators modulate a transistor between on and off states, greatly reducing the power dissipated as heat compared to a linear pass element that drops voltage continuously. As a result, switching designs commonly achieve efficiencies from 80% to well above 90% in many use cases, whereas linear regulators dissipate (Vin − Vout) * Iout as heat, resulting in poor efficiency when the drop is large. Therefore, the attribute that is generally superior is efficiency. Other attributes—circuit simplicity, acoustic/electrical noise, and cost—depend on context and are not universally better for switching solutions.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify the key physical difference: switch-mode devices avoid continuous dissipation by toggling.Relate dissipation to efficiency: lower loss → higher efficiency for the same output power.Compare typical results: switchers 80–95% vs. linear often well below when voltage drop is large.Conclude that “greater efficiency” is the best comparative completion.


Verification / Alternative check:
Thermal design confirms the point: linear regulators require larger heatsinks at the same load, reflecting lower efficiency. Switchers run cooler for the same output power in high-ratio conversions, validating the efficiency advantage.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Longer life: Lifetime depends on many parts (caps, environment); not universally superior for switchers.
  • Simpler circuitry: Linear regulators are typically simpler.
  • Lower cost: Both cost and BOM vary; cheap linears often win at low power.


Common Pitfalls:
Overgeneralizing beyond efficiency; some applications still prefer linears for noise simplicity despite lower efficiency.


Final Answer:
Greater efficiency.

More Questions from Operational Amplifiers

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion