Error Spotting – Choose the segment (A–D) that contains a grammatical error; select “No error” only if the entire sentence is correct. Sentence: A) On resuming his duty, B) he asked his Superiors C) that whether he would be D) permitted to leave early.
-
AOn resuming his duty,
-
Bhe asked his Superiors
-
Cthat whether he would be
-
Dpermitted to leave early.
-
ENo error.
Answer
Correct Answer: that whether he would be
Explanation
Introduction / Context:This item checks complementizer usage with reporting verbs like “ask”. English uses either a “that-clause” or an interrogative “whether/if-clause”, but not both simultaneously. Doubling them creates a faulty construction.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Main reporting verb: “asked”.
- Complement in C begins with “that whether …”.
- Intended meaning: he requested to know if permission would be granted.
Concept / Approach:With “ask”, use “whether/if” without “that”: “He asked whether he would be permitted …”. The sequence “that whether” is ungrammatical because English does not stack complementizers this way in standard usage.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) Identify the clause marker(s) introducing the content of “asked”.2) Remove “that” and keep the interrogative complementizer: “whether”.3) Correct clause: “he asked his superiors whether he would be permitted to leave early”.4) Therefore, the error resides in C.
Verification / Alternative check:Try parallel patterns: “asked whether/if …”, “said that …”. Mixing these leads to obvious awkwardness (“said whether that …”).
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- A: Absolute/participial opener is fine.
- B: Reporting frame is acceptable (capitalization of “Superiors” is stylistic).
- D: Passive complement is idiomatic.
Common Pitfalls:Stacking complementizers; translating directly from languages that allow “that whether” sequences.
Final Answer:Option C