Difficulty: Hard
Correct Answer: (sec A − tan A)^2
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question checks identity manipulation and rationalization in trigonometry. The expression (1 − sin A)/(1 + sin A) is commonly simplified by multiplying numerator and denominator by (1 − sin A) to remove the sum in the denominator and convert everything into cos A terms.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
Multiply by the conjugate (1 − sin A)/(1 − sin A):
(1 − sin A)/(1 + sin A) = (1 − sin A)^2 / (1 − sin^2 A).
Then use 1 − sin^2 A = cos^2 A. Finally rewrite (1 − sin A)/cos A as sec A − tan A, and square it.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1) Start:
(1 − sin A)/(1 + sin A)
2) Multiply numerator and denominator by (1 − sin A):
= (1 − sin A)^2 / ((1 + sin A)(1 − sin A))
3) Denominator becomes a difference of squares:
(1 + sin A)(1 − sin A) = 1 − sin^2 A
4) Use identity:
1 − sin^2 A = cos^2 A
5) So:
(1 − sin A)/(1 + sin A) = (1 − sin A)^2 / cos^2 A
6) Separate as a square:
= ((1 − sin A)/cos A)^2
7) Rewrite:
(1 − sin A)/cos A = 1/cos A − sin A/cos A = sec A − tan A
8) Final:
= (sec A − tan A)^2
Verification / Alternative check:
Take A = 30°: sin A = 1/2, cos A = √3/2.
LHS = (1 − 1/2)/(1 + 1/2) = (1/2)/(3/2) = 1/3.
RHS: sec A − tan A = (2/√3) − (1/√3) = 1/√3, square gives 1/3. Matches.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
• sec A − tan A (not squared) is not equal to the original ratio.
• sec A + tan A corresponds to a different identity.
• tan A or sec A alone cannot match the rationalized squared form.
Common Pitfalls:
• Forgetting to square after converting to (1 − sin A)^2/cos^2 A.
• Mistakenly using 1 − sin^2 A = 1 − cos^2 A.
Final Answer:
(sec A − tan A)^2
Discussion & Comments