In the following question on correct sentence structure, consider the sentence "No one was there on the platform after the train had left." Choose the option that best improves the underlined part, if required.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: No improvement

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This sentence improvement question checks your understanding of basic subject verb agreement and natural word order in English. The sentence No one was there on the platform after the train had left describes an empty platform following the departure of a train. The tested segment is was there on, and you must decide whether it needs any correction. The original sentence is already grammatical and idiomatic; it correctly uses was with the singular subject No one and places the adverb there in a natural position. Therefore, no change is necessary.


Given Data / Assumptions:
The sentence contains the following elements.

  • Subject: No one, which is singular.
  • Verb: was, in simple past tense.
  • Adverb: there, indicating presence at a place.
  • Prepositional phrase: on the platform, giving the specific location.
  • Time clause: after the train had left, describing the earlier event.


Concept / Approach:
In English, no one is treated as a singular pronoun and therefore takes a singular verb such as was. The sequence was there on the platform is a natural way to indicate that nobody was present at that location. The preposition on is correctly used with platform because we stand on a platform. The tense contrast between was (simple past) and had left (past perfect) is also appropriate, because the train left before the time being described. Since all parts of the sentence are grammatically correct and idiomatic, the best choice in a sentence improvement question is No improvement.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Step 1: Check subject verb agreement: No one is singular, so it must be followed by was, not were. Step 2: Examine the word order No one was there on the platform and confirm that it follows normal English patterns for stating presence at a place. Step 3: Verify preposition usage: we say on the platform, not in the platform or at the platform in this context. Step 4: Look at the time clause after the train had left and see that it correctly uses past perfect for the earlier action.


Verification / Alternative check:
Consider the meaning: after the train had left, the platform was empty. The sentence No one was there on the platform after the train had left expresses this clearly. If we change was to were, we get No one were, which is wrong because no one is singular. If we move there after on, as in was on there, the sentence becomes unnatural. Using none instead of no one is possible in some contexts, but None was there on the platform is less natural than the original and not an improvement. The original version matches how fluent speakers describe such a situation, confirming that no change is needed.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option A, No one were there on, is incorrect because were does not agree with the singular subject No one, and the phrase stops abruptly. Option B, No one was on there, misplaces there and sounds awkward; we do not usually say on there in this context. Option C, None was there on, again ends abruptly and replaces the natural subject No one with None in a way that does not improve the sentence. Option E, No one had been there on, changes the tense and leaves the sentence incomplete. Thus, the sentence requires no improvement, and option D is correct.


Common Pitfalls:
Some learners incorrectly treat pronouns like none and no one as plural and use plural verbs, leading to forms such as No one were or None were, which are not standard in exam English. Others attempt to change word order in an attempt to make the sentence sound more complex, but they actually make it less natural. In sentence improvement tasks, always check whether the original form is already correct before trying to alter it. If the grammar, agreement, and idiomatic usage are all fine, choosing No improvement is often the best option.


Final Answer:
The sentence is already correct as it stands, so the right choice is: No improvement.

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion