In the following sentence improvement question, choose the best version of the sentence: 'I wish I can help you.'

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: I wish I could help you.

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This question tests sentence improvement in English grammar, specifically the use of wish with unreal or hypothetical situations. In competitive exams, candidates are often asked to recognise correct structures used to express desires that are contrary to present reality. The sentence given is I wish I can help you. At first glance it looks almost correct, but the auxiliary verb can does not match the meaning of an unreal present wish. Understanding the correct pairing of wish with the appropriate modal verb is essential for accurate and natural English usage in both spoken and written communication.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The original sentence is: I wish I can help you.
  • The speaker wants to help but is unable to do so at present.
  • The task is to choose the grammatically best and most natural version of this sentence.
  • Options use different modal verbs and forms of help.


Concept / Approach:
When wish refers to a situation in the present that is unreal or not possible, English usually uses a past form of the verb to signal distance from reality. Therefore, we use could instead of can. The structure is I wish + subject + could + base verb for present unreal ability. This is similar to the pattern I wish I were richer or I wish I knew the answer. The idea is that the wish expresses regret or an impossible or unlikely situation in the present, not a real ability or permission.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify the meaning of the sentence. The speaker wants to help now but cannot; this is a hypothetical present situation.Step 2: Recall the rule: for present unreal wishes, use wish + past tense form or wish + could + base verb.Step 3: Compare options. Option A uses could help, which matches the pattern I wish I could help you.Step 4: Option B uses may, which typically expresses possibility or permission in the present or future, not an unreal wish.Step 5: Option C uses could helped, which is grammatically incorrect because could is always followed by the base form help, not the past form helped.Step 6: Option D repeats the incorrect original structure with can.Step 7: Conclude that Option A is the only grammatically correct and natural sentence.


Verification / Alternative check:
You can check the decision by comparing with other common examples. For instance, native speakers say I wish I could speak French or I wish I could visit you, not I wish I can speak French. If the speaker had the real ability, they would simply say I can help you. This contrast confirms that wish requires could when talking about an unreal or unfulfilled desire at the present time.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Option B: I wish I may help you mixes wish with may, which sounds unnatural in modern English for this meaning. May is rarely used after wish in this way.
  • Option C: I wish I could helped you is grammatically wrong because could must be followed by the base verb help, not the past form helped.
  • Option D: I wish I can help you repeats the incorrect form that fails to convey the unreal present situation correctly.


Common Pitfalls:
Candidates often confuse can and could, thinking that could only shows past ability. However, could is also used to express a hypothetical or unreal present or future situation. Another common mistake is to combine wish with may or might inappropriately. Remember that for regrets or unreal wishes about the present, English regularly uses wish + past tense or wish + could. This pattern is heavily tested in exams, so memorising typical examples will strengthen your accuracy and confidence.


Final Answer:
The best and grammatically correct improvement is I wish I could help you.

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion